It’s the fact that I already knew her voice before I knew her freckles. That I already wanted her online, in the dark, through a headset—back when she was a laugh in my ears and a streak of chaos that made everything feel easy.
Back then she wasn’t Rory Shields’ sister. She wasn’t a complication. She was just my SailorGirl.
And I was DreamBoat.
The one who teased her about living on cereal and iced coffee and owning twelve water bottles while still being dehydrated. The guy who curated a pirate themed playlist to set the soundtrack to our missions, and always called her out when she would rage-quit, then immediately re-queue.
The guy she trusted enough to meet at a coffee shop.
The guy who didn’t show up.
After I walked away, I did the only thing I could to manage the loss.
I got a tattoo.
It wasn’t because I think ink is romantic, but because I didn’t know what to do with the empty space where SailorGirl used to be. The late-night laughs. The easy connection. The version of me that showed up on a headset and then—like an idiot—didn’t show up in real life.
So, I did what I always do when I can’t fix something.
I found a controlled way to make it hurt.
I shift on the bed, and the movement tugs at my ribs—just enough to remind me it’s there. I drag my fingers lightly over the ink, skin still a little tender, like my body’s keeping receipts.
It was supposed to be a private compromise. A way to keep her close without dragging her into my mess.
And now she’s here. In Coral Cove. Training in the same facility. Walking the hallways with frosting on her face and my name in her mouth like it’s nothing.
Now she’s not just a voice in my ear.
She’s real.
Which means the tattoo doesn’t feel like a coping mechanism anymore. It feels like evidence. A confession.
But I can’t get close to her and not tell her who I am. It would only confirm I’m the kind of guy everyone thinks I am.
So I’ll keep my distance and keep my mouth shut.
But it’s not even going to be an issue, because Whitney wouldn’t choose me in the daylight. She’d take one look at my reputation and do the sensible thing.
Run.
It doesn’t matter anyways. Vivi told me to keep my head down and stay out of trouble.
And then there’s Leo who’s putting his neck on the line for me.
Instead of pretending I’m fine and letting my brain rot in silence, I scroll to his name and hit call before I can overthink it.
He answers immediately. “Please tell me this is a social call.”
I snort. “You say that like those are mutually exclusive.”
There’s a sigh on the other end—fond and long-suffering. “How’s Coral Cove?”
I glance around the pastel rental, the wicker chair judging me silently. “Sunny. Slow. There’s a cat.”
“Of course there is.”
“She’s a stray,” I add defensively. “I didn’t adopt her.”