“I’m still hurt.”
“I know.”
I swallow hard. “And I still don’t know what to do with the fact that I believe you.”
That one hits him harder. I see it in the way his face shifts, something in him going softer and rougher all at once.
“I know,” he says again, but this time it comes out quieter. “And I’m not asking you to figure any of that out tonight.”
I look down at my phone in my hand, then back at him. “Rory came in at a really inconvenient time.”
Connor lets out the smallest huff of laughter, dead tired and a little wrecked. “Yeah. I noticed.”
That drags a tired, reluctant half-laugh out of me before I can stop it, which feels wildly disloyal to my own emotional devastation, but there it is.
His eyes stay on me, careful and open.
I hate that I can still see how much he means every word. I hate that I still want comfort from him. And most of all, I hate that the wanting is winning.
“I walked the beach for two hours trying to get my head on straight,” I tell him.
Connor’s gaze flickers. “Did it help?”
“No.” I shake my head. “The ocean is annoyingly full of you now.”
That pulls something almost like a smile from him, brief and tender, then it’s gone.
Because the video is still here. His I love you is still sitting between us, too, breathing quietly in the room like something fragile neither of us knows how to touch yet.
I cross my arms, more to hold onto myself than to shut him out. “I hate that you said those things.”
His face tightens immediately. “I know.”
“I hate that some part of me heard them and went exactly where you’d expect.”
“You should hate it,” he says. “It was awful.”
“And I hate,” I add, my voice thinning in spite of me, “that after all of that, you’re still the person I wanted waiting here.”
He looks down for a second, drags a hand over his face, then back up at me. “Yeah,” he says quietly. “I wanted to be.”
A laugh slips out of me then, frayed at the edges and not very stable. “See? That’s the problem. You keep saying exactly the right thing at exactly the worst possible time.”
That one actually gets a full smile out of him. Then it fades, and we’re right back in it.
I look at my door again, then at him.
At the ugly, impossible mess of tonight still spread out between us.
Then I swipe my keycard and push the door open.
It’s not wide, but enough to be an invitation.
Connor’s eyes drop to the movement, then lift back to my face.
“I’m not saying everything’s okay,” I tell him. “I’m not saying I’m over it.”
He nods. “I know.”