. . .
CONNOR
She goes still. Not defensive, just perfectly quiet, like she’s searching for a way to turn this into a joke but coming up empty.
When she gives me the smallest nod, it feels like permission and a warning all at once.
“You weren’t just a voice in my headset anymore,” I say, my throat tightening around the words. “You weren’t just SailorGirl on a screen.”
I force myself to keep going, even when the next part sticks.
“You were real. And it scared the hell out of me.”
She doesn’t look away. Doesn’t blink.
And somehow that’s worse, because I can’t hide behind her anger if she’s simply listening.
“It hit me all at once,” I continue, voice roughening. “That I didn’t want to lose you.”
I see it register—the way her chest stills, like she’s bracing for something she doesn’t trust yet.
“I knew my name would change everything,” I say. “My reputation. Rory. The sponsorship mess. All of it.”
My gaze drags over her face, searching for the moment she decides I’m not worth it.
“And I panicked.”
Her eyes shine, just for a second. She’ll hate that I saw it.
“I left,” I admit, the words scraping on the way out. “Because it felt safer to have you think I was an asshole than to stand there and watch you decide I wasn’t worth it.”
She swallows hard.
I can feel her reaching for something—armor, distance, anything that lets her stay in control.
But I don’t stop.
“And then Coral Cove happened,” I say, quieter now. “And even knowing who I was, you didn’t look at me like I was a problem to manage.”
My voice dips before I can stop it.
“You looked at me like I was someone you wanted.”
That’s the part that still gets me. The way she saw me before she knew. The way she didn’t flinch.
“And I thought maybe I had a shot,” I say. “That if I showed you who I actually am first…maybe you wouldn’t walk away when you found out the rest.”
Her voice cuts in, tight. “So you kept lying.”
There’s no way around it.
“Yeah. I kept lying because I was scared,” I say, forcing myself not to soften it. “And because I was already falling for you.”
Her breath catches—small, sharp, like her body reacted before she could stop it.
“Fast,” I add. “Hard. And I knew I had to tell you. I just—” I shake my head once. “I didn’t want to lose what we had before I had to.”
The silence that follows is thick. Charged.