I could press inside her, and it would be game over. My body is already gearing up for that sensation. It would be so fucking perfect. Being inside her. Having her like that.
Except, I can’t.
She isn’t like the random hookups of my past.
“Hey,” I say softly, pulling back to look at her. My thumb tracing along her lips, still soft from our kiss. “You good?”
She smiles up at me, that mischievous gleam in her eyes. “I’d be even better if you were inside me.”
Her hands move over my arms, then glide along my shoulders before her fingertips tease down my chest. Her thumb grazes over the tattoo at my ribs. The sailboat. She thinks it’s a nod to my love of gaming and Sea of Thieves. There’s truth to that. But not all of it.
As she rocks against me, I almost lose control.
It’s clear this moment is designed to test me.
She’s so wet, so ready. So fucking needy. I could press my tip against her slickness and bury myself inside her in two seconds. Feel her walls grip me so damn tight as she takes every inch of me.
But with Whitney everything is different, and I can’t have her like this without having her trust. Because I want her first time with me to feel safe in every way.
I slow my movements. It’s subtle at first—my hips stutter, my hand on her thigh easing instead of gripping tighter, my mouth lingering instead of pushing forward.
She notices.
Her eyes flick up to mine, just for a second, like she’s checking in. Like she’s trying to read what just shifted.
That look alone almost makes me say screw it. Almost.
But I know what this is for her.
Tension. Chemistry. A way to burn something off.
And for me?
It’s already more than that.
So I force myself to pull back, and say the one thing I know will put a pause on this moment.
“I don’t have a condom.”
She stills beneath me.
“Oh, right.” She nods slowly, like she’s just remembering protection is an important part of sex.
Something flickers across her face, but it’s gone before I can fully catch it.
I hate that I can’t tell if it’s disappointment or confirmation.
Then, she presses her hand to my chest, not rough, but decisive.
“We should probably get ready to go. I’ve got to shower.”
I’m not ready for the distance, but she’s already moving. Out from under me. Off the bed. Toward the bathroom.
“Hey,” I reach for her wrist, but she’s gone before I can fix it.
She pauses at the bathroom door, glancing back just long enough to give me a small nod that feels way too final for what just happened.
“I get it.”