Then, I glance over at her, but she’s already reaching for the door.
We end up under a white tent strung with lights that don’t need to be on in the middle of a bright Sunday afternoon.
The whole street feels alive—bluegrass music playing somewhere down the block, people weaving between booths, kids running past with sticky hands and no supervision.
Whitney has a tray in one hand and a plastic spoon in the other like she’s been preparing for this moment her entire life.
“Okay,” she says, already scanning the lineup. “We need a system.”
“A system,” I repeat.
“Yes,” she says. “You can’t just go in blind. That’s how you get distracted by a good topping and miss a weak base.”
I watch her for a second, then realize she’s completely serious. And it does something to me I don’t have time to examine.
“Right,” I say. “Wouldn’t want to get outplayed by a topping.”
She points her spoon at me. “Exactly.”
I lift my hands. “I’m on board.”
And just like that, she takes over.
First sample—she pauses.
Second bite—her eyes close.
And that’s when I see it.
The shift.
The version of her that forgets to hold back. The one that forgets she’s mad at me.
“Okay,” she breathes. “That’s really good.”
I take a bite to confirm, but I’m not really focused on the cobbler. I’m focused on her.
The way she leans into things she enjoys without hesitation. The way her shoulders loosen, like she’s not carrying everything all at once.
She turns toward me, already mid-thought. “That one’s top three. You need to remember that.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
We move down the line like that—sharing trays, trading bites, her commentary getting sharper, funnier, more animated with each one.
“This crust is lazy.”
“That one’s overcompensating.”
“Too much cinnamon. That’s a cry for help.”
“You’re profiling these cobblers,” I say.
“They made choices,” she shoots back. “I’m reacting accordingly.”
I laugh, shaking my head.
She takes another bite, then freezes before slowly turning toward me.