Page 100 of Against the Current

Page List

Font Size:

When his eyes catch on the screen behind me, something flickers there.

Then I hear my own voice, quiet and wobbly with shock.

“Who’s DreamBoat?”

Pussy squirms out of my arms and hops down to the floor. She skitters past Connor and out the door like she’s got better things to do than witness human drama.

Still gripping the clothes, his arms drop to his side, like the weight of what he was carrying just became too much.

His throat works against a swallow. “It’s me, SailorGirl.”

The familiarity of his voice triggers a flashback of hearing him in my ears months ago.

But how is it possible I hadn’t put it together before this?

My mind is racing. Going over everything in the past few weeks. No, the past few months. My time gaming with DreamBoat. Then the nights playing with Connor and the flicker of recognition in his banter and playing style that I’d dismissed because what are the fucking chances Connor would be DreamBoat?

It’s me, SailorGirl.

It hits me. If he never made it to the coffee shop, then he would have found out I was SailorGirl the night I invited him over, and he didn’t say anything when I signed in. That would have been impossible for me to do if the roles had been reversed. Why didn’t he say anything?

“So that first time we hung out and you saw my gamertag? That’s when you found out who I was?”

He sets the clothing on the table by the door, then takes a step toward me.

“Connor, answer the question.”

“Please, Whit. I can explain.”

He looks defeated, but I refuse to back down.

“When did you know, Connor?” I ask, razor sharp.

“I was going to tell you. Tonight. I just⁠—”

“When. Did. You. Know?” I repeat slowly.

He opens his mouth to speak but hesitates. It’s that moment of hesitation that has my stomach plummeting. The taco digesting there is threatening revulsion. If I lose my stomach contents and it ruins Diego’s tacos for me, I’ll never forgive him.

He inhales shakily, like he’s taking his last big breath before revealing the truth. A truth that feels like it’s going to crush me.

“I was at the coffee shop.”

I didn’t think I could be more shocked tonight. He was at the coffee shop?

“Why didn’t you⁠—”

“I saw you waiting for me, then I left.”

“What?” My voice cracks.

Hot tears sting my eyes. Every emotion I felt when DreamBoat didn’t show up to the coffee shop comes rushing back. Sadness. Anger. Worry. Humiliation.

Sitting in the coffee shop with an empty chair across from me. The waitress checking on me as I waited, glancing at my phone to see if he’d messaged me. With every second that passed, the thoughts that he decided I was too much, not worth the effort, and changed his mind growing louder.

That had been mortifying.

But hearing that Connor was there…he watched me wait. He saw me. And then left. That makes it worse.


Novels you may like ...