Caelin’s eyes grow wide with alarm, obviously thinking something similar, and if I had a heart dropping feeling before, I now feel like I’ve waded into quicksand—and any move I make will just sink me faster.
So much for helping her make everything go perfectly.
Meanwhile, Colton’s jaw drops as he stares at Caelin and finally puts two and two together. “Wait… Caelin as in the maid of honor, Caelin? Are you telling me you were back here hooking up with the coach’s daughter, Cooper?” he yells, loudly enough to inform the whole damn county.
“Unbelievable,” Jake mutters, shaking his head. “Don’t you ever think before you do things?”
Embarrassment seeps through me; the sticky, familiar shame of the labels I’ve worn for so long, I can never quite peel them off. I don’t even dare to look at Caelin right now. I hate that she’s having to witness this, hear what my teammates really think of me. What they take me for.
“It’s not what it looks like…” I start, clenching my jaw in anger.
“It damn well better not be,” a deep voice cuts through the darkness like a knife.
And that’s when Coach Torres walks around the corner.
35
CAELIN
In the blink of an eye, the night before Christmas has transformed into The Nightmare Before Christmas.
“Coach Torres, I can explain,” Dallas says, stepping in front of me slightly as if acting on a subconscious protective instinct to shield me from whatever’s about to happen. “I should’ve told you this sooner, but the thing is, I lo—”
“With all due respect, now’s not the time, Cooper.” Dad holds up a hand, cutting Dallas off. His voice is firm, not harsh, but his eyes are steely. “I’ve seen and heard enough for one night already.” Then, almost under his breath, he adds, “One lifetime, actually.”
The insinuation in this is clear. Dad’s judging what he thinks he just witnessed unfairly—using Dallas’s past to assess a situation that’s happening in the present. And I’m not having it.
“Dad, no,” I say, stepping forward.
Dad’s expression morphs into one of concern as he looks at me. “Caelin, you’re freezing.” Shrugging off his sport coat, he drapes it around my wet shoulders. His tone now holds a note of accusation, and Dallas’s jaw tenses.
Frustration bubbles up in me. “I was the one who wanted to stay out here, it’s not his fault.”
“Don’t,” Dallas says softly. When I meet his eyes, they’re flat, and he shakes his head. “Your dad is right. You need to get warmed up, plus I’m sure Reagan’s wondering where you are. You should go back to the farmhouse.”
My mind spins as I stare at him, unsure what he’s doing right now. Why he would want me to leave instead of stay and fight.
Everything in me wants to dig my heels in; demand that all of us remain right here until my dad understands, but when I look at Dallas again, any words I might’ve had to say die in my throat.
“You should go get warmed up and check on your friend,” he says, sounding so unlike himself it makes my heart sink. “I’ll sort out the power issue and find Robbie while I’m over at the barn.”
I squeeze my own eyes shut, willing them not to tear up as I nod. “All right.”
Dad watches our interaction with his forehead wrinkled for a moment before he nods. First at us, then at his other players who’ve been unfortunate enough to witness this whole awkward conversation. “I’ll go back over there and let anyone left at the barn know you’re on your way to the fuse box, Dallas.”
He strides off and I swallow down the lump in my throat as I turn to look at Dallas again. He gives me a gentle smile, but it doesn’t quite meet his eyes. “Everything’s going to be fine. I’ll…see you tomorrow.”
“I’ll come with you, see if I can help get the power back on,” Aaron offers.
“I got it. Just—make sure Caelin gets back to the house okay?”
Aaron nods. “Of course.”
His eyes move over me with a flicker of what looks like regret, and then my heart constricts as he walks away.
Aaron, Jake, Colton and I all shuffle back to the farmhouse in supremely awkward silence—not even Colton has a wisecrack for a moment like this.
When we get back to the farmhouse, the guys mumble their goodnights before they head into the guesthouse over the detached garage, which Dallas’s truck is parked outside of. All of Jimmy’s groomsmen are staying up there tonight. Mrs. Cooper is staying in Atlanta with Claire and Asher for the holiday, so us girls have the run of the main farmhouse.