Yeah, because I wasn’t lying when I said she would’ve devastated me.
“Oh Lordy,” Claire whistles, skewering the moment. I look away. My sister pulls a half-empty bottle of rose out of the fridge, then tuts at me. “What night was this, then? And more to the point, what did you do this time, Dal?”
“What makes you so sure I was involved?” I demand as I open the silverware drawer. “And what do you mean, this time?”
Claire raises a smug brow. “Do I need to remind you of your visit to USG?”
I let out a heavy sigh as I set a handful of forks on the counter. “That was a million years ago; we don’t need to bring that up.”
“What, did you break the hearts of a bunch of sorority girls and leave them all inconsolable?” Caelin gives me a sassy smile. “It sounds like something you’d do.”
“I’ve never dated a sorority girl in my life, actually.”
Caelin steps around me and picks up the silverware. “Why do I not believe you?”
Meanwhile, Claire points at me in delight. “You haven’t told her about Sweet Little Baby Dallas yet, have you?”
Caelin drops a fork on the table with a clatter. “Who?!”
“The younger, much more innocent version of the man standing next to you who came to visit me at college at the end of my senior year.”
“This sounds like a story I need to hear,” Caelin says with a grin.
Claire nods. “You really do.”
“You really don’t,” I reply.
“Shh, your sister’s trying to tell a story, Cooper,” Caelin says with a devilish grin. Despite her initial protests that she couldn’t possibly intrude on our family supper, it’s clear Caelin’s loosened up in my sister’s company—and the two of them are already having a great time ganging up on me.
Claire takes a sip of her wine. “So at the time, Dallas was this super innocent nineteen-year-old kid who’d been so focused on making it in hockey, he’d never taken a moment to enjoy himself or let loose. Never had a girlfriend or attended a party. Just hockey, eat, sleep, repeat.”
“This can’t be Dallas Cooper you’re talking about.” Caelin clutches her hands to her heart in mock-horror, and my sister chuckles.
“Oh it was. You should have seen him back then—he was the biggest dork. And I mean that with all the love in the world, little bro.”
“What a beautiful sentiment,” I mutter, but I’m smiling. Somehow, I don’t mind Caelin seeing this side of my life. A side of it I’ve always felt the most myself in.
“That particular weekend, however, Dallas had just been drafted to the NHL, and he wanted to celebrate,” Claire ploughs on, ignoring my comment. “So ready, that when a group of seniors who had all of college to practice holding their alcohol invited him to do Jello shots with them, he went for it.”
Caelin raises her brows at me. “I can see where this might be going…”
“I doubt that,” I reply.
“He’s not wrong,” Claire confirms. “Because instead of throwing up or passing out like a normal person getting too drunk for the first time, Dallas disappeared without a trace, and we were all searching for him for hours.”
“Oh no,” Caelin giggles.
“The other girls eventually gave up and decided to call it a night…and the sorority president found him passed out on her bed shirtless. With a raccoon curled up next to him.” Claire snorts at the memory. “A wild raccoon that proceeded to chase her out of her own room with its teeth bared before returning to the bed for another nap with my stupid brother.”
Caelin sputters an incredulous laugh. “Is this true, Cooper?”
“You should have seen the scratches all over my chest after I relocated it back outside the next day,” I reply. “I had my first unofficial NHL practice not long after, and I had to lie about the origins of the marks.”
“So you’re telling me the origins of Dallas Cooper’s big reputation can be traced back to the amorous clutches of a raccoon?” Caelin chokes out, breathless with laughter.
“There was nothing amorous about that thing, believe me. It woke up that morning and chose violence,” I reply, my humor tinged with regret as I look at the woman in front of me. Why did I ever let myself accept that label; lean into it?
Caelin’s doubled over with laughter now, and Asher runs into the room, skidding on the tiles in his socks. “What’s so funny?”