I’m wrapping my towel around my waist when I realize only Aaron is left in the room with me.
He looks my way and smirks. “Did you know she was going to be here today?”
I blink innocently. “Who?”
“The Virgin Mary.” Aaron rolls his eyes. “Coach’s daughter, who do you think?”
“Nope, I had no idea.”
Aaron snickers. “I need to warn Perez who she is before dinner so he doesn’t drunkenly do something stupid in front of Coach tonight. He’d have him skating laps for weeks as punishment if he knew he’d called dibs on his daughter.”
“Make that months.” I laugh, trying not to look as ruffled as I feel.
While Colton thirsting after the bridesmaids didn’t bother me earlier, now knowing that the woman he was thirsting after was Caelin makes me want to punch him in the face.
Ridiculous, I know. As if he’d stand a chance with a woman like that.
As if either of us would.
“Do you know why she’s here?” I ask, trying not to sound too keen for the information I’m desperate for.
“I asked Jimmy after the game, and get this: Coach’s daughter and Reagan have been friends forever. She’s her maid of honor.” Aaron whistles. “Small world, huh?”
My mind tumbles back to Caelin saying her best friend was running late to the party…Jimmy was late that night, too.
Could we really have been waiting for the same damn people to show up at that party?
“Seriously small world,” I mutter.
Maybe if we’d gone straight downstairs to find our friends that night, I’d have learned who she was right away. And we never would’ve ended up talking ‘til sunrise, sitting on that rooftop with our shoulders touching and our eyes heavy. When she finally started to doze off, I reluctantly offered to book her an Uber—but not before I asked her for her number so I could take her out again the next night.
A number I never ended up calling.
“What the hell is that look, Coop?” Aaron asks suddenly.
“What look?” My head jerks up.
Our team captain waves his finger in my face. “Like a lovesick puppy mixed with someone who’s been kneed in the balls.”
I snort. “That’s an oddly specific visual.”
“You making that face because you’re still all hot for the coach’s daughter?”
“No,” I say quickly. Too quickly, because Aaron’s taunting expression becomes borderline incredulous.
“I was kidding, Cooper.” He stares at me in disbelief, and every fiber of my being begins to prickle with regret for ever telling him that I spent a night at a party with a mystery woman who turned out to be Caelin Torres. Thankfully, he’s the only person I told.
“Should I have been serious?” he asks with a frown.
“Dude, I literally met her once, forever ago. And she lives on the other side of the damn world. At least, she used to and I’m assuming she still does.” I tack on the last part like I haven’t looked at her Instagram posts of sunsets and street food and stray cats multiple times. Especially not that recent shot of her wearing a tangerine-orange swimsuit and a triumphant smile as she balances on a surfboard amidst the waves.
Aaron sits down on the bench right next to me. I look pointedly at his sweaty bare chest, right next to my sweaty bare chest, and raise my brows at him. “This is cozy, but you’re going to have to buy me dinner first.”
He ignores my stupid comment. “You didn’t actually answer my question.”
“Because you’re being ridiculous,” I tell him. What else is there to say? That I still think about her way too often? That I haven’t even been on a single date with a woman since, let alone touched one?
He’d never believe me.