Solis handed Miles the iPad. He scrolled through the coroner's report slowly, stopping at the photographs. The wire documentation was thorough — multiple close-up shots of the neck, the wrap pattern, the finished loop ends — and the burn site photography was similarly detailed, each site photographed individually and with a scale marker. Under the glaring lights of a coroner’s office, it all looked much worse.
He handed the iPad to Vic and walked the scene once in a slow, full circuit, taking in the positions of everything: the guardrail, the discolored gravel, and the tire impressions from Gill's truck still visible near the overlook's edge. He looked at where the burn site photographs placed each mark on the body relative to the scene itself. Then he walked the circuit a second time, more slowly.
It was on the second pass that something began to resolve. He went back to Vic and took the iPad, pulling up the wire photographs again. He stood with them for a long moment, then navigated to the burn site documentation.
“What is it?” Vic asked.
“The wire wrap,” he said. “Look at the finish on the loop ends.”
She took the iPad and looked. After a few seconds, she handed it back. "It's tighter on the left side than the right."
"And the overlap pattern is irregular in two places. Not enough to affect its function, but enough to notice." He navigated to the burn photographs. "And these. Look at the depth markers."
Solis came over. The three of them looked at the forearm photographs on the screen.
“That’s pretty shallow, right?” Solis asked.
“Compared to what we documented on Paula Oñate, yes. The placement is correct, the sites are consistent with the Elementalist framework, but the burns didn't go deep enough. Someone knew where to put them but didn't apply the same duration or pressure.”
Vic straightened. “So, the method is right, but the execution isn't.”
“The execution is close,” Miles said. “It's functional. Someone who didn't know what they were looking at would call it identical. But it's off in two independent ways, and both of those ways point in the same direction.” He looked at the guardrail. “This was done by someone who learned the technique secondhand. They knew the steps but hadn't done it before. It’s almost like they were hesitant.”
The three of them stood in the heat for a moment without speaking. Somewhere down the highway, a truck passed at speed and the sound of it rolled across the desert and faded.
“I thought it might be someone Caswell had been working with directly,” Solis said. “A partner we didn't identify during the surveillance, maybe.”
“It's possible,” Miles said. “But the surveillance on Caswell was thorough. Ten days of documented movement and we never identified a second person connected to his operation.” He looked at Solis. “Did anything in the warehouse suggest a second individual? Any forensic material that didn't match Caswell?”
“Nothing confirmed,” Solis said. “There were partial prints on two of the wire coils that the lab hasn't fully excluded yet, but nothing that pointed to a second person being operationally present. And since finding Gill’s body, another team went back for a secondary sweep, just in case.”
Miles nodded and looked out at the desert below the guardrail. It was both daunting and beautiful, the terrain rolling and folding in shades of rust and pale gold. It seemed like a random place to die. Unless, of course, it was a spot Gill had frequented.
“Any idea if this place is special to him?” he asked.
“Not sure, but the wife says he makes the drive at least once a week for a side gig he has.”
“Maybe the killer knew.”
They let this settle around them for a while before Solis spoke again. When she did, it was with an almost reverent tone, as if making sure they were respecting the dead.
“The Caswell details were never made public,” she said, echoing the conversation Miles and Vic had already had on the plane. “The wire wrap he was prepared to use, the burn placement…none of that appeared in any press coverage of his arrest. The forensic specifics stayed inside the task force documentation.”
“We know,” Vic said, arching an eyebrow at Miles. “This isn't the first time we've had this conversation.”
Miles acknowledged that with a slight nod. She was right. Earlier in the investigation, there had been a separate concern about how certain case details had surfaced outside official channels, details that had no business being anywhere except inside the task force's own files. That concern had never been fully resolved. It had been flagged, examined to a point, and then absorbed into the larger momentum of the investigation without a definitive answer. Now it was back, and it was sitting in front of them in the coroner's photographs on an iPad in the middle of a desert overlook.
“Are we talking about a potential leak on the task force?” Solis asked.
“Not specifically, but given the nature of what we’re looking at…I think maybe it needs to be discussed.”
Solis took that in without visible reaction. She was not a person who reacted to difficult information with anything other than focus, which Miles had noted during their first few days working together.
“What do you need from my office?” she asked.
“Full documentation of everyone who accessed the Caswell warehouse evidence file and the forensic photography between the night of the arrest and this morning,” Vic said. “Every access log, every download, every forwarded attachment.”
“I can have that pulled within the hour.”