For a while it's just the fire and the wind and the two of us eating, and it's not uncomfortable, which surprises me. I expected it to be. I've been braced for it since I carried her through the door.
Then she sets her spoon down.
"Can I ask you something."
"You've been asking me things for three hours."
"Yes, but this one I'm asking permission for, which shows growth." She wipes her hands on the napkin. "The picture. On your dresser."
Everything in me goes still.
"The two of you, that's obviously you and Luke, I got that. But there's a woman. Older. Hat pushed back, big laugh, kind of looks like she's about to tell a joke she's told a hundred times." She's smiling a little, easy, like this is a normal thing to talk about, because to her it is. "Is that your mother?”
"No."
It comes out of me flat and hard and about two seconds too fast.
She blinks.
"Oh. Sorry, I just assumed, because she's got the exact same…”
"I don't talk about it."
That lands in the middle of the table and sits there.
I hear my own voice and it's worse than I meant it. Not loud. Just closed, all the way closed, the door pulled to and the bolt thrown, and I watch her face change and I hate every second of it.
"Right." She picks her spoon back up. Sets it down again. "Okay. I'm sorry. That was, God, that was nosy, and you literally scraped me out of a snowbank tonight and I'm interrogating you about your family photos, which is, honestly, a lot even for me."
"Winter."
"No, it's fine, I do this, I fill silences with questions and sometimes they're the wrong ones and I don't always notice until I'm already…”
"Winter."
She stops.
I look at the bowl. At my hands. At the grain of a table I built myself six winters ago out of a windfall pine, because I needed something to do with my hands that year.
"Yeah," I say. "It's my mother.”
She doesn't say anything. Which, from her, is enormous.
"And I don't talk about her.” I stand up and take my bowl to the sink, and I make myself say the rest of it in a voice that isn't a growl, because none of this is her fault. "Not to you. Not to Luke. Not to anybody. It's not about you."
There's a long pause behind me.
"Okay," she says softly.
I run the water. Outside, the wind picks up and throws a fistful of snow against the glass, and I stand there with my hands in the hot and let it burn.
"There's more bread," I say, "if you want it."
And after a second I hear the chair creak, and the knife on the board, and she says, "I really, really want it," and just like that she lets me off the hook, and I don't understand her at all.
5
Winter