“It’s a sad one.”
“I’ve got a lot of sad already,” I reply softly, and to my surprise, Eli reaches over and takes my hand. I spare him a smile and turn my gaze back to Mr. Tatum. “One more won’t tip me over.”
He studies me like he’s deciding whether that’s true before he finally nods. “The fire was never solved. That stage was old, the wiring was older, and it went up in the middle of the night with nobody around. I worked that scene as careful as I ever worked anything, and I never could say for certain how it caught. No accelerant, no witnesses. I closed it undetermined and it’s stayed that way absent any additional proof.”
“The town said it was Bonnie Tutwiler,” I say.
He scoffs. “The town’s a fool with a telephone. Yeah… the mill decided little Bonnie done it, jealous over losing the crown.” He snorts. “’Cept Bonnie Tutwiler was at her own mama’s house that whole night with five other girls, all of ’em up giggling till dawn. I talked to every last one, and they all told it the same. Bonnie didn’t set that fire and I cleared her cold.” He shakes his head. “Didn’t matter to the mill, though. Her name was run through the mud.”
Eli releases my hand, leans forward with forearms on his knees. “So if you cleared Bonnie and the fire was undetermined, what’s the sad part?”
Bo Tatum looks at him, then at me. “The sad part,” he says softly, “before I was able to conclude the investigation, when the mill was chewing Bonnie Tutwiler to pieces, your mama sent me a letter and confessed to the crime.”
The air is sucked out of my lungs. “She… what?”
Tatum nods. “I received a letter at the station two days after the fire. She wrote that we needed to leave Bonnie alone because she set the fire.”
“But why would she do that?” I murmur aloud.
“Didn’t you just hear me… because the mill was focused on her best friend Bonnie and she thought she’d take the heat off her. No other reason.”
And yeah… that makes sense. My mom was trying to protect her friend. Of course she’d do that.
“And she left right after,” I muse out loud.
“No one saw her again. Sent me that letter and then left town like a ghost. And that poor girl had just buried her mama a few months before.”
“Did you believe her?” Eli asks quietly.
“Not for one second.” Bo’s pale eyes are steady. “Because I’d worked that scene, son. There wasn’t a thing about it pointed to Melissa Rhodes, or to anybody. In fact, I didn’t even bother to try to interview her after that letter because to me it was clear she was doing it to pull the mill off Bonnie Tutwiler and onto herself.” He lets that sit. “It was the bravest, dumbest, saddest thing I ever saw a young person do.”
I can’t breathe. Beside me I feel Eli go still. “She left because she was afraid she’d get arrested. She figured she’d confess, leave town and that would be the end of it.”
Bo nods sadly. “I’m guessing that’s the way of it. I suppose she ran because she thought she was in trouble. Thought she’d confessed to a crime and the law was coming for her. Thought she had to disappear.” His voice roughens. “When the truth is there wasn’t a soul coming after her. Not one. She could’ve stayed. She could’ve grieved her mama and lived her whole life right here.”
The room blurs and I press my hand to my mouth.
She ran for nothing.
She gave up Whynot, her name, her whole self, running from an arrest that was never, ever coming. She did it to protect a friend from a rumor and nobody could tell her otherwise, because by the time anybody understood, she’d already made herself impossible to find.
Anger rises within me. Against whoever set that fire and let the fallout happen, to the Gossip Mill for assuming it was Bonnie, which in turn made my mom feel like she had to confess to a crime she didn’t commit, which in turn had her giving up her entire life.
“She built a whole other person,” I say, my voice cracking wide open. “A different name. A different life. She married my dad, she raised me and my brother, she died an entire other woman. She spent her whole life hiding from a crime that didn’t exist.”
Bo Tatum looks at me, and his old eyes are wet. “Hoped she landed soft somewhere. Sounds like she did, at least, if she had you.” He nods at me, gruff, kind. “That’s something. That’s more than I let myself hope, most nights.”
Eli’s hand finds the small of my back, warm and steadying, and I lean into it. I don’t have any armor left for this. I don’t even know how to reach for it.
“Mr. Tatum,” I say, when I can. “Did Bonnie ever know my mom confessed and tried to take the blame for her?”
The old man spreads his hands. “That I couldn’t tell you. I so completely discounted that confession letter, I never told anyone about it. Far as I know, the only two people who ever knew Melissa confessed were her and me.” He shrugs. “Whether she told Bonnie, whether those two girls ever hashed it out before Melissa run off… I got no idea. You’d have to ask Bonnie.”
That’s definitely my next move.
Because it’s not just that Bonnie was my mother’s best friend anymore. It’s that my mother threw her entire life onto a fire to protect this woman, and I don’t know if Bonnie ever knew. I don’t know if that sacrifice is the wound that made my mother cut off everyone she ever loved, Bonnie included. I don’t know if somewhere in Raleigh there’s a woman who’s spent thirty-five years missing a friend who vanished, never knowing that friend gave up everything for her.
I have to find her. Not for the facts anymore. The facts are almost done. I have to find Bonnie Tutwiler because she’s the last living piece of my mother’s heart, and because somebody in this story deserves to finally know the truth. I think it might be both of us.