“So, we’ve heard a bit about Jessie’s reasoning for the separation. Dan, how do you feel about the separation?”
He huffs out an angry breath. “Upset. Pissed off. Confused.”
“Good start. Identifying what you’re feeling is important. Tell us more about how it felt to have Jessie want to end things. What went through your mind after the phone conversation while you were in Arizona?”
“I didn’t believe her. I thought it was a terrible fight and she’d come around.”
Makes sense considering he kept trying to call and text me during those couple of weeks. He thought if he could get me to talk, I’d forgive him and let it all go. Just like every other time he let me down, he thought he could sweet-talk me into forgiving him.
Of course, he didn’t realize every time he did it, every time I let it happen, it was like sweeping broken glass under a rug. You couldn’t see the problem anymore, but it didn’t mean it was gone. Eventually, when you break too many glasses, you run out of space under the rug and have nowhere to hide the broken pieces.
“Had you fought like this before? Had she mentioned ending your marriage in the past?” Theresa probes with a serious look on her face.
“No,” he grits out through clenched teeth. “But I didn’t want to see it. It took our friend Bailey being brutally honest for me to wrap my head around the fact that she meant it when she said she was done. That’s when I got on a plane to come home. I wasn’t gonna let her go without a fight, but then the accident happened, and she was there. I thought she was giving us a second chance, but she left again.”
I scoff. “It wasn’t a second chance! It was more like a tenth chance. I’ve been giving us chances for years.”
“But I didn’t know. You never told me you were unhappy.”
Theresa turns her gaze to me. “Would you say this is true, Jessie? Did you tell Dan you were unhappy with your marriage?”
I think for a beat before responding. “I guess not in those exact words, but we’ve been fighting over when he’d retire and when we’d have kids for years. I’ve been begging him to be more present and pay more attention for so long. Doesn’t it seem telling that he didn’t even know I was unhappy?”
“Okay. We’ll get to hashing out everything, but let’s table the past for a few minutes and do an exercise. I’m going to give you each a piece of paper and about ten minutes to make a list of the things you need from each other in your marriage. This could be anything from financial stability to weekly date nights. Whatever you need to feel loved and valued by the other person. Write them down and then we’ll discuss.”
She gives us paper and sets a timer. I go about carefully making my list. What would make me feel loved and valued? Do I even know anymore?
When the timer goes off, I look back at the list and cringe at how few of these have been met over the years. I can see where she’s going with this, and it’s not gonna be pretty.
“Alright, Dan. You start. Read out your list,” Theresa says with an encouraging smile.
“Okay. One: support my career. Two: uh, sex.” He glances at Theresa, but she gives him a nod to continue. “Three: to feel secure in our relationship. That’s all I have. I’m a pretty simple guy.” He shrugs and clears his throat.
“Completely fine. Now, how many of those would you say Jessie was meeting before the separation?”
“Before spring training, I would have said all of them. Sometimes, I may not have felt one hundred percent supported in my career, especially with her pushing for me to retire. But yeah, for the most part, she was meeting all of them.”
She gives him a nod and turns her gaze to me. “Jessie, go ahead and share your list.”
I clear my throat and read my paper. “One: having a say on big life decisions and feeling like a full partner. Two: feeling supported in my business. Three: being able to trust he’ll do what he says. Four: quality time where he feels present and is actively paying attention. And five: physical intimacy.”
I put my list down on my lap, and I can see Dan studying me out of the corner of my eye. The dread starts in my chest as I wait for Theresa to ask her next question.
“And how many of those needs was Dan meeting?”
I take a deep breath and blow it out. I risk a glance at Dan, who has his forehead furrowed and a frown on his face.
“Just number five.”
“So physical intimacy was the only need being met,” Theresa clarifies.
“Um, yes, there were times when some others were fine. Especially early in our marriage, but over the last few years, not as much.”
Theresa lets a moment of silence hang over us.
“Dan, you look upset. Tell us what you’re feeling.”
“I guess stunned. I had no idea she felt this way. Why didn’t you say something? Years, Jessie? You’ve been feeling this way for years and never said anything?”