Page 102 of Butterfly Proposal

Page List

Font Size:

Let that sink in.

Whatever Phoenix Vale allegedly put into a Night Theory song is so personal, Effie Devaux is willing to reveal one of the most closely guarded secrets of her life to stop him from releasing it. Suddenly those whispers about lawyers make a whole lot more sense.

But there is more.

Because, per usual, there is always more.

Witnesses say Effie also confronted Phoenix about Tully, the iconic drummer for Night Theory, making disturbing allegations about an incident that resulted in Effie receiving medical treatment. Effie claims she has photographs.

And medical records.

And witnesses.

She also threatened to pursue charges and expose Phoenix's role in covering up said incident.

Neither Vale nor representatives for Night Theory have responded to requests for comment regarding those allegations.

But whatever was said on that beach apparently struck a nerve. That's when the altercation turned physical.

Witnesses allege Phoenix grabbed Effie by the throat.

The throat, I tell you!

And Chief Dean Moretti?

He arrived in climactic fashion.

Mama would love to say cooler heads prevailed. Alas, they did not.

Sources describe the Winslet police chief charging onto the beach, ripping Phoenix away from Effie, and proceeding to introduce the rockstar's face to what we're told is a very impressive right hook. Then a left. Then a gut punch.

Wash, dry, repeat.

According to witnesses, Phoenix attempted to fight back—emphasis on attempted.

One source described the confrontation rather succinctly. "It wasn't even close."

Another added, "Phoenix Vale is built for a stage. Dean Moretti is built for war."

I'll leave you with that visual.

Witnesses report Moretti repeatedly struck Phoenix as crew members scrambled around the confrontation, with Effie eventually stepping in and convincing the newest love of her life to stop. Not to save her ex, but rather because Vale was not, and I quote, worth it.

Chief Moretti then did something no Night Theory fan had on their bingo card for the year. He pulled out his handcuffs.

Phoenix Vale—the man who headlines Night Theory, sells out arenas, and spent years building a reputation as one of rock music's most untouchable bad boys—was reportedly face-down in the sand on the shore of Lake Winslet while his ex-girlfriend's fiancé handcuffed him.

I simply cannot make this up.

Phoenix was arrested at the scene and is said to be facing charges related to the alleged assault and trespassing on private property. But not before delivering one final warning...

According to witnesses, Vale warned Devaux, "You'll pay for this,” and followed that up with, "I'll get you one way or the other."

Not exactly words of the heartbroken romantic we've been hearing from these past few weeks. Which brings us to the spicy question we suspect everyone is now asking.

What exactly happened between Phoenix Vale and Effie Devaux?

Because for months, the public story was relatively simple:


Novels you may like ...