Reluctantly, they nodded.
Kaida drew in a breath. “The first time it happened, I was a child. I had no understanding of what was occurring.” Her voice shifted, softer now, pulled back into memory. “I had gone for an early morning swim. I’d ridden my pony down to the beach to escape another lesson my father had insisted upon.” A faint, humorless breath left her. “But when I dove into the ocean…my body tore itself apart.”
Piper’s hand tightened around her glass.
“I thought I was dying,” Kaida continued. “That something beneath the surface had found me. That I was being attacked.” Her throat tightened. “But it was me. My own body.” She swallowed. “My legs fused. My bones shifted. And I became something I had only ever heard of in stories.” Her gaze lifted to meet theirs. “A mermaid.”
Silence fell again.
Kaida told them she had gone to her father, and how he had listened—really listened—as she tried to explain what had happened to her.
How he had not recoiled.
How he had not questioned her sanity or dismissed it as childish imagination.
He had believed her.
She spoke of the way he had pulled her into his arms when the shaking wouldn’t stop, how his hand had rested steady against the back of her head as though he could quiet the storm inside her by sheer will alone.
How he had told her she was not broken.
Her lips pressed together.
“And I believed him,” she admitted quietly.
For a moment, something flickered across her face—grief, sharp and fleeting, before it hardened into something else.
“And then…” Her fingers tightened slightly around the glass in her hand. “What came after.”
The ships.
The treasures.
The blood.
The men.
The countless lives she had ended before they had ever had the chance to mean anything.
“At first, I told myself it was necessary,” she said, her voice beginning to strain despite her control. “That it was for our people. For our kingdom. Because that’s what he told me.” Her gaze dropped, unfocused now, somewhere far from the room. “They were traders. Sailors. Men trying to make their way home.” She ran a shaky hand over her face. “I remember their faces.” Her voice broke then, cracking despite her efforts to hold it together. “I remember every single one.” The tears came before she could stop them, slipping free as she dragged in a sharp breath, her composure fracturing under the weight of it.
Piper’s expression shifted first—disgust and horror softening into something deeper, something that ached to look at. Sympathy. Grief for her friend.
Kaida forced herself to continue. “My mission in Nyvaris…” she said, her voice quieter now, steadier only through sheer will. “Yes, the treaty is real.” A deep breath. “But that is not why I was sent.”
Their attention sharpened instantly.
“I was sent to assassinate the Ocean Prince.”
The words landed heavy between them.
Kaida didn’t look away. She told them then—of Reave. Of how it had started with tension, with mistrust sharpened into something almost unbearable.
“How I thought I despised him,” she said, a faint, hollow breath of something that might once have been humor escaping her. Her gaze flicked briefly to the side, as though she could still see him there. “But somewhere along the way…” Her voice softened without her permission. “He stopped being the enemy.”
She told them of the quiet moments—the ones no one else had seen.
Of the way he had looked at her when he thought she wasn’t paying attention.