I go to the dates.
The fourteenth.
Nothing.
There's no row for the fourteenth. There's no row for that whole week. The most recent one I have is from September.
Then I look at the receipt again. Because it still says exit nineteen and he still told me he was at Karma, four blocks from my apartment, and he had blood dried on him.
I go back through the exit nineteen receipts one at a time, oldest first, and every time I get a date I type it into the phone and look.
July ninth.
Eddie.
Eddie, who called his mother every Sunday for nine years. Eddie, whose mother has his phone records in a shoebox because she read somewhere that a person could ask for them, and nobody had ever asked her for them until me.
I put the phone face down on the table.
Because up until right now this has been a column. Up until right now I've been putting dates against dates.
August nineteenth. Anthony Roach.
September first. Victor Pell.
September twenty-second. Luis Obando.
I stop typing them in because my hands have started shaking uncontrollably, so I go back to the drawer I've already been through and find a pen, and I turn over a Karma drink menu and write them by hand instead.
Nine of them. Nine late fills at exit nineteen and nine nights a man in my spreadsheet stopped existing.
And then I go back to the one at the end. The fourteenth. The one with no name next to it.
Because now I know what that is. That's a man nobody has reported. That's a row in my spreadsheet that isn't a row yet, and it was eleven days ago, and the next morning I was asleep with his arm across my chest.
I sit in a chair in my boyfriend's kitchen with his cat asleep on a pile of paper, and I say it out loud, because nothing's real to me until I've heard it out loud.
"He wasn't at the bar."
Jerry doesn't react.
"He wasn't upstairs either."
Exit nineteen is Kingston, and Kingston is Ulster County, and Ulster County puts its property records online. I know that because I spent a day searching their database once for a piece about a man who owned nine buildings under five different names.
Jackson’s last name is not a common last name. I type it in.
A house on four acres outside Woodstock. Recorded decades ago to a man with the same last name and a first name I’ve never heard before, then transferred ten years ago to Jackson.
There's a photograph still attached to the old sale listing. Washed out, crooked, taken from the bottom of the drive. A brown house with the trees closing over the top of it and a gravel driveway.
So, he has another property. One that it looks like he’s been sneaking away to.
I write the address on the drink menu under the nine dates.
And then I pick up the phone.
I type nine, one. My thumb sits over the one and stays there.