A few moments later, a light flicks on in one apartment. It could be a coincidence, or it could be Theodore’s apartment.
Only one way to find out.
Slipping past the old man chowing down on the wings, I take the fire escape, doing my damn best not to make much noise but I’m a big man, so it’s not that easy.
“You better not fucking break,” I hiss as the sound of metal creaks under me.
When I get to the window, I press my back against the wall and slide down into a crouch, trying my best not to be seen by anyone passing by.
There’s some sounds of movement in the apartment before everything goes quiet. Then the sound of a TV fills the room. It’s low, like it’s put on for background noise.
Careful not to make a sound, I peek my head to the side, looking through the open window.
Someone should really tell him that it’s not smart to leave your window open, not in an apartment with a fire escape. It’s too easy for someone to break in.
Theodore is sitting on his couch. His coffee table is littered with loose papers as he shuffles through them.
He starts to murmur to himself. I can’t make out much of what he’s saying. I get a few words here and there. “There has to be something more.” And, “Could it be him?”
Could who be what?
Me? Is he talking about me?
Who does he think I am?
I’m not sure what is going on, but I have a strong feeling whatever this man is working on for his story, it goes much deeper than what he’s led me to believe.
And I plan on finding out what that is. I have to protect myself. I can’t be too careful. Not when I literally murder people. If this man is sniffing around me, I have to know why.
Or maybe I’m just finding excuses to see him again. This man who has me out of my damn mind stalking and climbing fire escapes in the middle of the damn night.
This is not like me. Not at all.
Yet, as I make my way back down to the street, I’m planning all the ways I’m going to follow this man for the answers I need.
FOUR
THEODORE
Someone’s following me.
I've counted him… at least I think it's a him, four times in six blocks, which is three more times than statistics will let me call an accident. I know this because I looked it up. If you pass the same stranger once, that's a city. Twice, that's a coincidence. Four times in six blocks is a decision somebody made.
I don't turn around. I've read enough about this to know that turning around tells them you know, and once they know you know, the situation changes and stops being one you can walk out of.
So I do the reasonable thing, which is walk into a bodega and buy a banana I don't want and stand in the fluorescent light for ten minutes pretending to consider the chips.
When I come out, he's gone.
I eat the banana on the walk home because I paid for it.
Here's the thing about me that I've stopped being embarrassed about.
When something frightens me, my brain doesn't do the thing other people's brains do, where the fear turns into a feeling and the feeling turns into calling somebody. Mine goes straight to arithmetic. It starts sorting and building lists.
So by the time I get my door locked I've already worked out the three possibilities, in order of how likely they are:
One. It's nothing. It's someone who lives near me and works near where I work and we keep the same hours. Probability, honestly, sixty percent. This city is known for coincidences.