“I know what you’re about to tell me,” Hanna says. “I just didn’t want you to say it yet.”
Zoe is almost indignant. “That can’t possibly be true,” she says. “I’ve barely figured out how to say it, myself.”
There’s a thread of defiance in Hanna’s voice when she says, “I wanted to see your face when I told you about the offer. I wanted you to look at me—the way you look at me when it’s just the two of us. But I didn’t want to do it before . . .” She huffs, frustrated.
Zoe feels like her chest will burst wide open if Hanna says so much as another word. Darling, she thinks, but it comes out sounding a little bit more like, “You’re right. That’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard.”
Hanna flashes her a deeply disgruntled look. “Dimples,” she says, as if she’s calling out an illegal move in a game of chess.
Zoe blinks. “What—”
“You get them,” Hanna waves her fingers at her own face, furrowing her brow. “When you smile. When you seem, I don’t know. Genuinely happy? And sometimes it feels like—” There’s a heavy pause. Hanna is flushed a deep red now. She swallows, looking uncharacteristically nervous. “Sometimes when you look at me, I feel like—”
“You make me happy.”
It takes Zoe a second to catch up to the fact that she’s actually said it.
Fucking finally.
Hanna blinks back at her, her eyes flitting between Zoe’s own, shiny with sudden tears. Zoe feels like there’s still something she’s missing, still something she doesn’t understand. She wants to crawl into Hanna’s chest, and squeeze her whole body around her big, beautiful heart.
“Yeah.” Hanna breathes it out. “It feels like that. And I know it’s not—I could see what you were thinking, that morning after the party, before I left your place. That you knew it wasn’t going to work for you that way. And I mean, I get it, right? Why would you want a friends-with-benefits situation with someone who won’t even let you—return the favor, or whatever?”
And, oh, no.
Oh god.
Zoe Zuydervelt really is a bad person.
Zoe’s head spins with the reality of exactly how thoroughly she’s turned Hanna around, how confused she’s allowed her to become. “I’m so sorry,” she says, squeezing Hanna’s thigh, bringing her other hand over for good measure, “But that’s not at all—”
Hanna closes her eyes, shaking her head decisively, balling her hands into fists. “No,” she says, “I’m the one who should be apologizing. I was stalling you on purpose. I thought maybe if I could stop you from ending this . . . whatever you want to call what’s been happening between us, then at least this weekend I could still have you.” She falters, taking in a quick breath, her bottom lip trembling. “Even if you don’t—even if I don’t get to keep you.”
The feeling rises inside Zoe again, even stronger this time, unstoppable as a wave, or an avalanche. “Darling,” she says, almost lightheaded with the relief of finally letting it spill out, “you make me happy.” She grabs Hanna’s fists, pulls them into her belly, anything to have her closer. “It’s all you. It’s been you from the start. You’ve been so kind, and so patient, all this time, and I—I haven’t been fair to you at all.”
Hanna is just looking at her, uncomprehending, tearful, her fingers now clutching Zoe’s own.
“I’ve been acting like an idiot,” Zoe admits, angry at herself. “I’ve been so focused on the ways I’ve been hurt before that I treated you like a liability instead of the extraordinary person you are. I hurt you, and told myself I was protecting us both. I was wrong, and I’m so terribly, terribly sorry.”
Hanna’s eyebrows tick up. She shakes her head, almost imperceptibly, as if she can’t decide whether to argue with her or ask for clarification. “So, that first weekend,” she says, “at Alma’s cabin—”
Zoe is crying now, too. “God,” she says, bringing Hanna’s hands to her face, pressing her lips to her sugar-dusted knuckles. “I wanted you, so much. I want all of you, if you’ll still have me.”
“Zoe.” One of Hanna’s hands twitches out of her hold, but instead of moving it away, like Zoe fears, she uses the pad of her thumb to trace the outline of Zoe’s bottom lip. The gentleness of it makes Zoe shiver. “How could I not?”
Zoe can feel her last defenses failing, bringing down the already fractured walls around her heart. She allows herself to be buoyed by the kindness in Hanna’s expression, the soft creases around her eyes and mouth, that familiar, solitary freckle at the corner of her lip. Zoe is bolstered by the certainty she finds there, that seemingly boundless grace. “I don’t think,” she confesses, “that I’ve ever wanted anyone the way that I want you.”
Hanna is quiet for a moment. And then she rasps, “Why didn’t you just tell me?”
“I was scared,” Zoe concedes, surprised by how easy it is to say it, after hiding it all this time. “I don’t think I’ve ever met anyone like you before. But there have been people that made me feel the way you do. And there’s always been a point where trusting them ended up nearly costing me everything I had. And Alma, her family—they’re the one thing I’ve managed by some miracle not to mess up. I couldn’t imagine jeopardizing that, just because I’m—”
Yours.
“—so inexorably drawn to you.”
Hanna’s eyebrow crease is back in full force. “I don’t know what that means.”
Zoe giggles wetly, pressing a kiss into Hanna’s palm. “You’re an English teacher.”