The switch flipped from four men pissed at Simon to four men staring at Keith. The man of the hour suddenly looked a lot less confident.
“Now, I didn’t come here to fight you, Mr. McHaulty,” he continued. “I came here to ask you nicely to remove that picture. But what did you do? You kicked up a fuss and called a man who isn’t even here to defend himself several derogatory names. That’s why I hit you. I may be new to town but I’m not new to being decent.”
Simon crossed his arms over his chest.
“Now, take down the picture or I’ll get the law involved.”
Keith dared to sneer. His cheek was already starting to puff up. Simon didn’t think he’d hit him that hard, but he had wanted him to get the point.
“Why do you care? Who even are you?” Keith asked, still exasperated. “Are you sweet on Maximiliano? Is that it? Because I hate to tell you, man, but there are plenty of other confused guys out there. There’s no reason for you to jump into the guy’s bed just because he’s cute holding a pair of fuck-me underwear.”
Simon took a step forward. Keith took a step back.
Mateo stayed cussing.
“I’m his boss,” Simon answered. “And I’m not leaving until that picture and story are taken down. And, since you don’t know me, I’ll go ahead and sincerely suggest you do as I say.”
Simon decided he wasn’t going to threaten the man anymore. That, maybe, he was going to hit him again instead.
One look around the room later, Keith surprised Simon by nodding.
“Fine, I’ll take it down,” he said. “But only because I’m sure your employee isn’t done with the spotlight just yet. I’ll get another story one way or the other.”
Mateo growled. Simon tried to decide if he should hit the other side of Keith’s face or aim for the same place again.
Both swiveled their attention when a new voice entered their discussion.
It was worn but absolutely angry.
“Don’t you two worry. I’m going to make sure he doesn’t pull this stunt again.”
An older woman with gray hair in a tight braid stepped into view.
Keith’s face went white.
Where Simon expected a rebuttal from the man, there was nothing but silence.
The older woman gave Simon a curt nod.
“You two just go on back to your work. And tell young Max, Keith is truly sorry. Or he will be after I get done with him.”
Like she parted the Red Sea every week, the men around Keith dispersed with nary a word. Mateo took Simon’s elbow and led him outside, also silent. It wasn’t until they were back in his Jeep that Mateo howled in laughter.
“Do you— Do you know who that was?” he asked, wiping at his eye.
“That woman? No.”
Mateo nearly lost it again.
“Holy shit, man. I can’t— I can’t believe it.” He pointed through the windshield toward the clubhouse. “That— That was Betty. She owns the clubhouse. She’s also— She’s also Keith’s mom!”
Mateo was rolling in laughter now.
Simon found himself smiling into it.
Max did say Arbor Bay was like a big, dysfunctional family.
He just hadn’t realized how literal that could be.