“Why not? It is. That little girl inside you who is always bossed around is finding very clever ways to prove she’s the boss of her own life. That’s amazing. I love it.” He holds my gaze. “I love you. Every part of you. And every part of me wants to earn back the trust of every part of you, too.”
I exhale shakily. “One thing at a time.”
“Right.” He smiles. “That first night. You were driven by spite…”
“And then you appeared in front of me, and you were so tall and handsome and just exuded responsibility, like… sure, my sister was training to be a doctor, and I didn’t have a career path of any sort, but it didn’t matter, because the hottest helicopter pilot in town wanted to buy me a drink.”
“Did you know who I was before I introduced myself?”
“Hell yes. Everyone knew who you were the minute you moved to Pine Harbour. You were a catch.”
“I had no idea.”
“That made you even more of a catch. And I thought…this is the guy to finally do it with.”
“Is that what you called it in your sweet little mind? You wanted to do it?” He grins, and it’s so soft and natural, crinkling his face all the way to his eyes, that I realize it’s been a long time since I’ve seen Nate really just smile. “God, I really took advantage of you.”
“Not at all. That was the best day of my life. I felt like a princess. You took such good care of me. It was everything I wanted for my first time, and then the morning after was just so…” I hold my breath, overwhelmed by the memory now. How romantic it had been, how sky-high it set my expectations for the rest of our relationship.
Nate probably doesn’t even remember all the little things that made it so special.
But he surprises me. “I thought breakfast in bed was the least I could do. Full-service hookup, in the hopes that I might convince you that it should be more than just one time.”
“And you had the newspaper on the tray.”
“You teased me for being an old man.”
“You weren’t that old.”
“Maybe it was just that you were young.”
“Definitely.” I groan and tip my head back, leaning it against the couch. “I didn’t even know they still delivered newspapers!”
“You were too young for me. But I wanted you anyway.” He drags in a deep breath, tension vibrating through his body. “I still do, so fucking much it hurts.”
Everything goes still after that admission. I don’t move. He doesn’t move. I’m staring up at his ceiling. The Christmas lights are really pretty.
Finally, I whisper, “Remember doing the crossword puzzle together?”
There’s a pause before he nods, and I feel it more than see it.
“One of the clues was the most wonderful time of the year.”
“Christmas,” he murmurs. “And I said, not accurate in my experience. And you said—”
“That’s too bad, maybe I’ll make your holidays better this year.”
Nate touches my chin, drawing my face sideways to look at him, then dragging his fingers down my neck to curl his hand around my nape as he holds my gaze. “You did make it better. Infinitely better. So good, every year, and I’m sorry I was an ogre about decorating for the holidays.”
“I forgot just how hard they were for you.” I bite my lower lip. “It’s bittersweet, looking back at that morning.”
“Yeah, for me, too. It was so easy to fall in love with you, to give you what I thought you wanted, what you needed. But in hindsight, I should have questioned why it was so easy, and what we were missing.” He rubs his thumb along the side of my throat. “Somewhere along the way, I lost track of how to really take care of you. And don’t tell me that’s not my job. It is. You may not need me now in the same way. I know you’re strong and capable. But you deserve to be taken care of. And I need you. I need my wife back. I need another chance to be the husband you deserve.”
“What kind of husband do you think I deserve?”
“One who hungers for you. One who can’t keep his hands off you. Can I kiss you, Cassie? Can I show you how much I want my wife?”
“I thought you said no kissing,” I whisper.