Shaye said something about the life-changing shit that happens to us when we’re twelve, but I think about Cassie being told she was too much, by everyone, much younger than that. And I realize my own memories of being buffeted by chaos and rules go back much earlier than I thought.
“Inside me,” I say, starting again, “is a little boy who learned very early on that different people want different things, and those things are often in conflict. Maybe always in conflict. And he learned that he had to be what others wanted him to be, and hide what he really wanted because it caused problems. He knows all about being trouble, Cass. He doesn’t think a little whirlwind of a girl is too much at all. He would want to hold her hand.”
Cassie slides her fingers into mine, weaving our hands together.
“What do you need, Cass? Not what you think I want to hear. What you really need, deep down. Tell me.”
“I don’t know. I never know. I need to do things to figure out if they’re what I need.”
And that’s the difference between us in a nutshell. Cassie’s a natural explorer and I have a rigid sense of self that feels so brittle it might shatter if I try something new.
But when I think about her as a little girl, I just want to protect that natural curiosity. Fucking hell.
“Then we’ll do things. Whatever you want.” I’m getting choked up.
“You said that on our first date.” Cassie squeezes my fingers and edges closer to me. “Do you remember?”
“No. I wish I did. I remember so much of that night, but I was in my head, too.”
“Nate…” She breathes my name again as she curves in, not crawling on me, not kissing me, but…close. “I don’t want to fight anymore.”
“We need to keep talking. And we’re so different. It’s okay if we fight.”
“I know. But we’ve done enough fighting for tonight.” Her other hand comes up and her fingers hover just a hair off my lips. “Tell me what you wanted that first night, when you first saw me. Before you found out I was a virgin and you said we would do whatever I wanted.”
“I don’t remember.” It’s a reflex.
“Are you sure?” Her voice is so, so gentle. “I bet you’ve thought about that night from every different angle over the last year.”
I groan. “How do you know that about me?”
“Because I love you.”
Chapter 25
Cassie
Nate’s eyes flare bright with a hope so raw it takes my breath away.
I didn’t mean to say that. That’s a secret I’ve been holding inside, because admitting that I still love Nate, that I’ll always love him no matter what, feels like ceding ground in an important battle.
But I don’t know what that fight is over anymore.
And Nate is opening up in ways he never did when we lived together, real and vulnerable ways that make it impossible not to reassure him that I see him, and I love him, exactly as he is.
“Can I tell you what I remember?” I lick my lips, suddenly nervous. But it’s a good kind of nerves.
“Fuck yes. Please.”
“I’d had a weird week. I was working full-time at the farm, living at home, and Rory and I had a fight about what I was doing with my life. And then she apologized via text message, and said that she was studying all weekend, so she appreciated that I had a better work-life balance than she did. I went out that night to prove a point. A lot of my joy is driven by spite, a stubborn determination to prove my family wrong.”
“That’s as good a reason as any.”
“Is it?” I laugh under my breath. “Pawsatively Perfect is my spite project to prove everyone wrong.”
He chuckles with me. “That’s fantastic.”
“No, you can’t say that.”