“I’m running out of time.” He lifts my chin, his fingers strong and warm against my skin. But when our gazes meet, I see a real vulnerability in his eyes.
It’s not the first time that I’ve seen Nate have deep, hard feelings. We had lots of good moments of honesty in our marriage. Brief flashes of earnest connection. But he would always blink it away, lock it down. He saw it as a weakness.
Now, though, he holds my gaze and lets me look my fill, which is hard. Really hard. Because I like to flee from my feelings, too.
“Any day now, you could serve me with divorce papers. And I wouldn’t have a leg to stand on to protest it, even though it’s the last thing in this world that I want. You have proved that you are better off without me, and I’m glad you’re happy, but I wish— God, Cass, I wish I’d done everything differently. I may not know what to do with you, but I want to.”
My head is buzzing like it’s full of angry bees.
“I’m sorry I let you think for even a second that I’d have a date for tonight. There hasn’t been anyone else. And there won’t be, not when I can only think about you. There’s never going to be anyone else, because you haunt my fucking dreams. You’re a goddamn menace. And I corner you because I want your anger, I want you to be mad at me, I want to sit in the fire with you and figure this out. I want to pin you down and tell you there won’t be a divorce, not as long as—”
A knock at the door stops me from responding.
Nate swears under his breath. “One second.”
“It’s Garrett,” my brother-in-law says from the other side.
Nate’s hold on my shoulders tightens. “I know it’s a big ask. And it might take time. It might not work at all. Just…give me that time. Please.”
I plant my hands on his chest and he lets me move him out of the way, even though I can feel the tension vibrating through his body.
“We’re going to head out,” Garrett says when I open the door. “Rory’s exhausted.”
“We’ll come say goodbye,” Nate says for the both of us.
I glare at him as he navigates us together as one. He’s suddenly decided that the key to whatever it is he wants with me—another chance?—is to put his hands on my body in a possessive, bossy way as often as possible.
But not kiss me back.
It makes me furious, and everyone in the kitchen immediately picks up on that vibe, as if we’ve brought a bickering tidal wave with us that sweeps everyone out the door.
We push past each other, jockeying for position as we both try to wave goodbye to my sister, who has hustled out to Garrett’s truck so fast you’d think she was running away from something.
Or two someones.
“We’re going to go as well,” Ben says. He gestures to Shaye and Theo and Campbell, who are all pulling on their coats. “I’m giving these guys a ride home. Thanks for a fun night. Merry Christmas.”
And suddenly it’s just my family. My parents, my baby sister, and…Nate.
But instead of grabbing me again and dragging me back to the Stuff Room, or upstairs to my childhood bedroom where I’m going to sleep tonight, Nate just stares at me.
His expression is so hard to read.
And after a fraught, confusing beat, he abruptly reaches for his coat. “That’s my cue to leave, too.”
I open my mouth to say no, you can stay, but he really can’t. There isn’t enough privacy in this house to finish our argument, not without guests to distract my family. And the problem is that when we start fighting, we don’t stop. Everything gets brought up, rehashed, like there’s no expiry date on old grievances.
If he stays, we’re going to ruin Christmas for my parents.
But if I let him leave, I’m going to ruin Christmas for myself. Because I don’t want him to go, I realize with horror. I want him to stay, even if we’re going to be fighting. Even if it means going to bed so mad I’m steaming.
I’d rather be furious with Nate than go to bed alone, aching for him, knowing he’s all alone, too.
There’s never going to be anyone else as long as you haunt my fucking dreams.
His words repeat in my head, becoming my own thoughts, because they ring so true. He haunts me just as much as I apparently haunt him.
Chapter 24