“Oh wow, would you look here, look at you. I barely even recognized you,” he says, his gaze raking down my body like he’s already undressing me with his eyes. “You’ve changed in all the best ways, Bunny. Those hips… that ass… fuck.”
My stomach churns violently. I know that voice, it's one that I’ve been trying to forget for years. I don’t even need to turn around to know who is standing behind me, but I turn reluctantly, as though each move toward facing him again feels like a betrayal of everything I’ve fought so hard to move on from. There he stands, like a shadow I’ve never truly escaped from, Trevor Hayes. The man who once whispered sweet promises to me, promises that now feel like cruel jokes. The man who I'd once thought had been my entire world until responsibility knocked on his door, and he chose to take the easy way out, the man who left me, pregnant and alone. He still looks the same as I remember, only older and more gray, with that same infuriating smirk as always, but where his presence once used to excite me, now only ignites my anger.
My throat tightens, but I force myself to meet his gaze. “What the hell do you want, Trevor?” I ask, my voice steady, though inside, I’m boiling over, but I refuse to let him see me falter.
“So hostile.” He takes a slow step toward me, his gaze raking over my body like he still has some right to look at me that way. “I’m just surprised to see you after all this time. You were always beautiful, but now...” His eyes lingered a little too long, making my skin crawl. “You’re... incredible.”
The way he says it, like he is running his hands over me with his eyes, makes every muscle in my body stiffen. I swallow back the bile rising in my throat and attempt to maintain my composure, even as my pulse races.
“Save it, Trevor, I’m not interested in a trip down memory lane.”
“Oh come on, why you gotta be like that, Bunny?” he tries in an attempt to stir up something familiar, but all it does is stir up my lunch.
“I’m not your Bunny,” I snap, the old nickname burning like acid. “Don’t call me that, don’t act like you still know me.”
He huffs, like he’s trying to hide his irritation, then in a move that makes every warning bell go off in my head, he takes a step closer to me, too close for my comfort. Then he reaches out, brushing a strand of hair behind my ear with the kind of familiarity that makes my skin crawl. The gesture is casual, like we're old friends, when we're anything but.
I take a step back, my eyes hardening at him. “Don’t touch me,” I demand, my voice colder than I’ve ever heard before.
He chuckles, the sound low and a little too intimate for my taste. “Come on, Paige. You don’t have to be so defensive. We both know the chemistry we used to have, that kind of thing doesn’t just disappear, does it? You can act distant all you want, but I still know you, better than anyone, I bet I still know exactly what makes you fall apart.” His voice drops lower. “I bet some nights you still think about me. About how good we were together. Tell me you don’t still get wet thinking about me.”
The audacity of this man. I can’t help the bitter laugh that escapes my mouth, and for a second, I let myself take him in, this man who thinks he still has power over me after everything he’s done. My heart is racing with a cocktail of emotions, disgust, rage, but above all, I feel a sense of calm because I know who I am now.
“You’re disgusting,” I exclaim, shaking my head. “You think you can just show up after all these years and talk to me like this? Like you didn’t leave me pregnant and alone? Like you didn’t tell me to get rid of my baby so you could go back to living your perfect little life with your wife and kids?”
His laugh, bitter and mocking. “You really think you did the right thing?” he asks, his words dripping with venom, his gaze now predatory as it rakes over me. “You could’ve had so much more. We could’ve had so much more if you hadn’t just gotten rid of it like I told you to. You had to throw your whole life away for one mistake.”
His words are a slap, but they no longer have the same sting, not when I know the truth, not when I have so much more happiness than he could ever comprehend. I glare at him, my anger rising. “Zoey isn’t a mistake. She’s the best thing that ever happened to me. And you? You couldn’t handle the responsibility, so you took the easy way out. Don’t come at me, acting all high and mighty, pretending you didn’t do everything in your power to avoid owning up to your own actions. I bet your wife still doesn’t know what you’ve done. I bet she doesn’t even know the kind of man you really are. Or did she finally figure it out and leave you?”
Trevor’s jaw clenches, and for a moment, I see something flash in his eyes, anger, regret, maybe guilt, though it’s quickly masked by a flicker of amusement. “Unbelievable,” he mutters, shaking his head. “You actually think you’re better than me? You really think you made the right choice?”
I didn’t even get a chance to retort before Zoey’s voice pierces the tension like a ray of sunshine. “Mommy!”
My heart soars in my chest at the sound of her, that sweet voice that can melt away any fear, any doubt I’m having. I turn in time to see Zoey’s little form weaving through the crowd, her curls bouncing with each step, her eyes wide with excitement. As Zoey reaches me, I instinctively step in front of her, blocking her from Trevor’s view, like a shield, and then I feel it, Zach’s presence beside me. His strong, steady presence that always seems to calm the storm in my chest. The second he sees Trevor standing way too close, his entire demeanor shifts. His jaw tightens as he steps forward, placing himself between us with calm, deliberate authority.
Trevor’s eyes snap to Zoey, and his entire body recoils like he’s been electrocuted, his face draining of all color in an instant as he turns a sickly shade of ashen gray. His eyes wide, and his mouth falls open in a silent, horrified gasp, as he stumbles backward, nearly losing his balance as his hand flies up to clutch at his chest. For a moment, he looks like he might throw up right there on the pavement, his throat working visibly as he swallows hard, over and over. He stares at Zoey like she’s his personal nightmare come to life, his breathing fast and shallow, sweat already glistening on his forehead.
“That’s the kid?” he rasps, his voice cracking, barely recognizable. “You really kept the fucking kid?”
Zach stares him down, his voice low, steady, and ice cold. “You’re going to shut your mouth, and you’re going to walk away right now.” He lets the words hang, his broad frame unmoving, eyes locked on Trevor with unrelenting intensity. Zach continues, his voice dangerously calm, “Don’t make me repeat myself, you don’t exist to us, you’re just a ghost from the past, where you’re going to stay, and if you ever try to change that… I’ll make sure you understand exactly how permanent that decision was.”
Trevor blinks, his gaze flicks between us, sizing up Zach like he is trying to figure out who the hell he is. “What, are you her new knight in shining armor? You think you can just step in and—”
Zach’s eyes flash with an intensity that makes my stomach flip. His jaw clenches, and the words that follow are laced with a level of danger that sends a different kind of shiver down my spine.
“Listen to me, Hayes,” Zach’s voice booms loud like thunder, cutting through the growing tension. “You don’t get to stand here and throw your words around like you have any claim on either one of them, because you don’t. As far as you’re concerned, both of those girls,” Zach points at Zoey and I, “are mine. You hear me? And now?” His jaw tightening as he takes another step forward, closing the space between them. “Now, you’re going to get the hell out of our lives, you’re never going to look at them, you’re never going to think about them again, not now, not ever.”
Trevor’s eyes narrow, an ugly sneer pulling at his lips. “Oh, I get it, you're the guy playing house with my leftovers. Must feel real good pretending to be daddy to someone else’s kid.”
Zach’s expression doesn’t change, but the air around him instantly grows colder. He leans in slightly, his voice dropping even lower. “I’m not pretending anything except that I don’t want to kick your ass right now. Now get the fuck out of here before I stop being polite.”
Trevor holds his glare for another second, breathing hard, but the combination of Zach’s size, calm intensity, and unyielding stare rattles him, but before he can respond a young woman’s voice cuts through the tension.
“Trevor, babe, there you are, I’ve been looking everywhere for you.” A pretty, young woman, maybe twenty-three at most, approaches from behind Trevor. Her eyes are bright and trusting as she slips her arm through his. She looks at all of us with polite confusion, unaware of the storm she walked into. “Is everything okay?” she asks, her voice soft and sweet.
Trevor’s face tightens and for a split second, I see the panic flash across his features before he forces a smile. “Of course, Bunny, everything’s fine, just ran into some old… acquaintances.”
The sight of her hits me like a punch to the chest, she’s me from years ago, young, hopeful, and clearly believing every lie he’s told her, like I had. The same situation, the same man. I can’t stop the laugh that escapes me at the irony of it all.