“Of course he is,” I mutter, exhaling through my nose, dragging a hand over my face. “I need you to understand how serious I was about this cat.”
“Oh, I understand,” she teases, still smiling through the tears. “That’s what makes it so funny. It’s actually kind of impressive,” she jests, “You were ready to go full rescue mode for him.”
“Yeah,” I laugh. “Apparently I’m out here about to form full scale search and rescue operations for a stuffed animal.”
Her shoulders finally drop a little at that, like the weight on them has eased enough for her to breathe without forcing it. “Don’t tell Zoey you were this invested,” she jokes, still sniffling. “She’ll never let you live it down.”
I glance toward the hallway again. “Oh, I’m absolutely telling Zoey, I want credit for my dedication.”
That earns a real laugh from her now, quick and broken but genuine and just like that, the tension that’s been sitting on her shoulders all night finally eases, it’s not gone, but there’s something about the way she’s smiling through it, even while she’s still falling apart that does something to my chest, and for the first time tonight, she looks like she might breathe a little easier.
“I should probably try to get some sleep,” she says after a moment, her voice sounding tired.
“Yeah,” I agree quietly, though neither of us moves right away.
She hesitates, then offers a small, uncertain smile. “Thank you for… everything tonight.”
I shake my head slightly. “You don’t have to thank me.”
But she does anyway, in the way she looks at me for a second longer than she should before turning toward the hallway.
“Goodnight, Zach.”
“Goodnight, Paige,” I repeat, quieter.
She steps back, slow, reluctant and the second she’s out of my space, it hits me. This hollow, unfamiliar ache, like I’ve lost something I wasn’t supposed to let go of. She lingers for half a second longer, her eyes meeting mine again. There’s gratitude there. Softness. Something fragile and uncertain that pulls at something deep in my chest. Then she turns and disappears down the hall, and I stand there, in the aftermath of something that feels a hell of a lot bigger than a late-night conversation in a kitchen. It feels inevitable, like something I’ve been walking toward without even realizing it, and for the first time in a long time… I don’t want to step back, not from her, not from this, not from whatever the hell this is turning into and that realization lands heavy, solid, and impossible to ignore, and as I stand there in the empty kitchen, one thing becomes painfully, terrifyingly clear, I’m already in this way deeper than I ever meant to be.
12
Three’s Company
ZACH
The smell of pancakes fills the kitchen the next morning, warm and sweet, the batter hissing softly on the griddle as I flip the pancakes one by one. The rhythm of cooking helps more than it should, a way to occupy my hands and distract my restless mind. I’ve already set the table with plates, syrup, and a small dish of butter. Zoey deserves a good breakfast, and Paige… well, she deserves something, too, though I’m not sure pancakes are enough.
They’re not like anything I expected. Paige isn’t simply guarded in the way people usually are, it’s deeper than that, like she’s built her life around not needing anyone because needing someone feels like something she can’t afford. She’s somehow stronger than I could’ve imagined, even last night, as everything was falling apart, she was still trying to keep herself together for her daughter. And Zoey, God, Zoey, she’s the kind of kid you want to protect, to keep safe from every bad thing in the world and I can’t remember the last time I felt like this.
But that’s the thing, isn’t it? I’m not supposed to want this, I’m not supposed to want to be here in my space with them, offering them a place to stay like we’re some kind of family. I’ve spent my whole life avoiding attachment, avoiding the kind of commitment that makes you vulnerable, but with them, it feels different, with them, it feels like everything that I’ve been running from is exactly what I needed.
As I flip the last pancake onto the stack and exhale slowly, trying to settle the restlessness inside me, the kind that comes after something important has already started to shift without your permission. This isn’t what I do, I respond, I leave, I don’t… stay, I don’t get attached, but I can’t ignore the way it feels like I’ve stepped into something I’m not sure I know how to step back out of, like I’ve already stepped into something that no longer feels temporary, something I could’ve never planned for. It should make me pull back, make me reset, to remind myself of what lines are supposed to look like. Instead, I’m standing here, watching the steam rise off the pancakes, wondering when exactly I stopped thinking of this as a situation I was helping with… and started thinking of it as something I can’t walk away from.
A floorboard creaks softly behind me and I turn to see Paige standing in the doorway, barefoot, her hair slightly mussed from sleep, though her face still showing traces of exhaustion lingering from the night before. She’s wearing my oversized clothes that I gave her last night, and something about that sight tugs at me all over again. For a split second, I forget everything else as I watch her, standing there in my kitchen, in my clothes, looking so… vulnerable. It’s a side of her I don’t think she shares often, the weight of everything she’s been carrying beneath the surface. She’s a mother, a protector, a fighter, but right now, she’s… human.
“Morning,” I announce, setting the spatula down, forcing my voice to sound lighter than how I’m feeling. “Hope you like pancakes.”
Her lips twitch, not quite forming a smile, and her eyes are still heavy. “Morning. You didn’t have to do all this.”
I shrug, a faint smile tugging at the corner of my mouth. “I wanted to, besides I’ve been told I make a mean pancake, so really this is more of a public service than anything else.” I try to make it sound like a joke, but there’s something more underneath, something that feels real, something that’s been brewing ever since she walked into that bodega and into my life six months ago.
She raises an eyebrow, a small smile tugging at the corners of her lips, but it’s fleeting, like she’s unsure whether she can afford to fully trust me yet. Her eyes flicker over the pancakes, then back to me, and for a brief moment, I wonder if she’s seeing me as something more than the guy who helped them out last night. Paige looks at me for a moment, as if trying to read something in my expression, and maybe she sees it, or maybe she doesn’t, but whatever it is, she doesn’t press the issue any further, and maybe it’s wishful thinking, but it feels like something shifts between us in that small, silent space. It’s a quiet recognition of… something, maybe it’s nothing more than everything finally catching up to us all at once, or maybe it’s something that’s been there from the start, finally making itself known.
“Mommy, look! Pancakes!” Zoey’s voice breaks through the moment before it can stretch any longer, her small feet padding quickly across the floor as she runs in and grabs Paige’s hand, excitement lighting up her entire face with the innocence and joy that only a child can carry. Paige laughs, the sound light and warm, edging towards something that almost sounds real instead of practiced. It’s a relief, in a way, like the weight of the night is slowly being lifted off her piece by piece.
“I see, baby,” she says, taking Zoey’s hand and letting herself be pulled toward the table.
Watching the two of them together does something to me I wasn’t prepared for, something that I used to not know how to name but I think I’m starting to learn. The way Zoey leans into her without hesitation, the way Paige adjusts around her instinctively, like it’s second nature to carry the weight of someone else’s world without letting it show. It isn’t simply love, it’s resilience, it’s everything she’s had to hold together, quietly and consistently, without anyone stepping in to take some of the weight off her shoulders, until now.
We settle around the table, the light from the window spilling over us, casting a soft, warm light on the room. Zoey digs in, her tiny hands clutching the fork with more enthusiasm than precision. Paige, on the other hand, picks at her food, her gaze distant as she looks down at her plate. The silence stretches between us, but it’s a comfortable one, filled with the hum of Zoey’s chatter and the occasional scrape of a fork against the plate.