“Okay, okay, think. He is going to come down here. He has a gun.”
Jennie fought for her logic to overcome her panic. “But he doesn’t necessarily know we’re down here.”
“So, what, we hide and surprise him?”
“Yes. Where were those pipes?”
They felt their way along the walls, locating the construction debris, and selecting lengths of pipe to hold like clubs. Then they groped their way back into the furthest alcove from the trapdoor and crouched inside it.
Miles handed Jennie the light. “The second he steps past this wall, you shine the light right in his eyes, I’ll hit him on the head, and we make a run for it.”
“Miles—”
The sound of the trapdoor scraping open echoed throughout the corridor. They huddled together in darkness, holding tight to their makeshift clubs.
The door clanged shut, and the strong beam of an actual flashlight cut through the dark. Jennie closed her eyes against the brightness. “If anyone’s down here,” Maurice’s voice called, “they’d better come out now. I’ve had enough surprises for one night.”
The footsteps and light moved closer to where Jennie and Miles hid, pausing to explore each alcove. Jennie clutched her pipe, powdery with corrosion, and pressed herself hard against the stones. She breathed through her nose, trying to keep from hyperventilating. She thought about the lengths Marcella Porter had gone to hide the Midnight, how frightened she had clearly been of its powers. The flashlight’s beam illuminated the bricked-up end of the passage. She should have listened to her warnings.
“Now!” yelled Miles. Jennie flicked on the bike light and thrust it in front of her, shining it at Maurice as Miles leapt behind him, pipe raised. But the metal, after decades in the damp basement, was not used to such rough handling. The makeshift weapon cracked in half, and the top spun away from the bottom, bouncing harmlessly off the wall. Maurice whirled around, gun pointed at Miles, who stood with hands over his head with the broken pipe.
“Drop it, Jennie, or I shoot him in the stomach!” Maurice hissed. She let go her length of pipe. It hit the ground and also rudely broke into pieces.
“Turn off your light. Now. Go stand next to him,” the dealer commanded. “Both of you against the brick wall.” For the second time that night, they did as they were told.
Maurice sighed heavily and wiped his brow with his sleeve. “What is the problem with you two? Do you see how you’ve escalated things? Nobody needed to get hurt.”
“Nobody except Peter,” said Jennie, using every ounce of willpower to keep her voice steady.
“Peter?” said Maurice, incredulously. “Peter, like you, became greedy. Stumbled across something much bigger than he was capable of grasping. Whatever happened to him is his own doing.”
“A person deserves to die because he won’t sell you a stupid locket?” said Miles.
Maurice turned his eyes to Miles. “I really am sorry you’re here. You’ve been so loyal, to this point. I didn’t mean for you to get mixed up in this. But, as we learned back at Green-Wood, it’s a bit unwieldy for me to manage both of you. I’m afraid I’m going to kill you first, as she’s the one who seems to know everything.” He raised the pistol and Miles flinched.
“NO!” screamed Jennie. “STOP. Stop, please. I have the diamond. You can have it, just leave him alone.”
Both men turned to her.
“Show me,” said Maurice.
Jennie moved forward off the wall, until she was standing parallel to the alcove’s opening.
“What are you doing?” Maurice said, taking a step back. “Show me the fucking diamond, Jennie.”
“Don’t do it,” said Miles, bewildered. “If you give him what he wants, he’ll kill us after—”
“That’s not fair,” interrupted Maurice, his teeth gleaming, “to assume the worst of people. Now, Jennie. If you cooperate, you’ll find that I’m quite a reasonable person. And cooperating means you are going to show me the diamond this fucking minute.”
“I will. I am. Just, wait.” This was it. From her pocket, she lifted the faux jewel, the trinket left over from Marcella Porter’s party. She prayed that in the uneven light of the flashlight, it was a passable dupe for the Midnight. She let it twist and glitter, dangling it like a carrot in front of a donkey.
Maurice gasped. “Give it here!”
“Put down your gun.”
“Not in a million fucking years.” He pointed it at the floor and fired. The bullet pinged off the flagstones and lodged in the brick wall behind Jennie. Miles shouted and moved toward her, but he froze when Maurice pointed the gun back at him. Jennie flinched but held her ground.
“The diamond. Now. Trust me that I will hurt you. Trust me that I have done worse to people for less.”