Jennie
Lee told Jennie to take the rest of the week off. She declined. The thought of being alone in her apartment, with nothing to do but relive the events at Glamorama, filled her with dread. And besides, there was something about Peter’s death that nagged at her. A question that could only be answered in the Diamond District: the message scrawled on the Little Hope auction flier. Not safe. Those two words lodged in Jennie’s tired and troubled mind, planting a seed of suspicion that Pete’s death was not as simple as an old man having a heart attack. She even looked up the medication in his pocket. It wasn’t for a heart condition, just a daily pill for acid reflux. And after all, the owners of Little Hope had disappeared. Clearly something about the abandoned shop was off. Could Pete have gotten mixed up in it?
So at 9:00 a.m. sharp that Thursday, she arrived at Little Hope Jewelry Corp., waiting for the auction to begin. Hoping that behind the gold-lettered door, she’d find something to explain the strange message, to dispel her unwelcome suspicions. She was alone. Maybe it was the norm for auctions to start fashionably late on Forty-Seventh Street? She wouldn’t be surprised. After a few days in the Diamond District, she’d already learned there were all sorts of quirks to how things were done. Deals worth six figures were closed with a handshake. The choicest rubies were described as “pigeon’s blood.” Tiny diamonds were called “melee.” Huge stones were folded into worn paper parcels and carried around in plastic smiley-face takeout bags.
On moral grounds, Jennie was no fan of “Business Island,” as she referred to Manhattan. But, even though grief and guilt hung heavy over her that week, she’d begun to appreciate the District’s inadvertent stand against contemporary sameness and slick corporate interfaces. Despite its run-down neon aesthetics, Jennie saw the block as an old-fashioned village where men gathered in the streets to talk shop, and everybody knew a bit about everybody’s business. The fact that she was Lee’s employee, that she’d been close with Peter, ensured she was given a warm reception into this village. Kind words and fond memories of her Uncle Pete were offered in every backroom workshop she visited.
The old-world feel of the District tapped into something deep for Jennie. She’d always been drawn to old things, always carried a false nostalgia for times long before her own birth. Not that she didn’t appreciate the internet and modern medicine and all of that. But something about how life was lived nowadays left her empty and questioning. Uncle Pete, who’d run a local antique shop, encouraged her in her love of the past, taking the time to point out the precise stitching on an embroidered sampler, the furniture maker’s stamp on the back of a mirror. Every object was made by someone who believed it to be beautiful or useful, he said. Every object is a story.
She’d majored in history when she went to college, of course, only to quickly become disillusioned by how it was presented. To her, the big words and tiny footnotes sanitized a messy and fascinating past. So she started experimenting with art. Using objects to tell the story of the past, just like Pete had taught her. But her own present became messy soon enough. Senior year her mother was diagnosed with cancer. It had always been just the two of them, and Jennie moved home to be her caretaker. It took three years for her mom to die. Jennie spent those years at the hospital and picking up shifts at the local diner. That was where she met her ex. He was the line cook and he made her smiley faces with eggs and bacon when she had a bad day.
At the funeral, surrounded by her mother’s friends and colleagues and well-wishers, she felt completely lost. She’d been so focused on caring for her mom. Now, she had no idea what to do. She told this to Pete, who’d stood beside her in the receiving line. “Come to New York City, dear Jennie. There, you will find every option available to choose from. Call me when you arrive, and I’ll help you get settled.” She’d only taken half of his advice. Stunned when she was accepted to Pratt’s MFA program with her paltry portfolio, she took it as a sign that she was destined for success as an artist. The universe owed her something good, after all. She moved to Brooklyn with no plan B. And though she thought often of calling Pete, she kept putting it off. He was a link to her mother, and the sadness she was trying to bury.
As Jennie reminisced, her feelings devolved into the familiar swirl of guilt and shame. The naïve belief that success in her chosen profession was guaranteed. The spent money. The broken relationship. The ruined opportunity. The fact that she hadn’t contacted Pete until she’d needed help finding a job. She wondered if this guilt wasn’t the real source of her suspicion about his death. If she wanted to find somebody to blame for the tragedy, for robbing her of the chance to restart her relationship. She turned to go.
“Can I help you?”
Jennie startled at an older man wearing blue coveralls and towing a janitor’s cart. “No, well—yes, actually.” Not safe, the note had said. “I’m here for the auction.”
“You’re early.”
“Just a few minutes, if anything . . .”
“Three hours and a few minutes. It starts at noon.”
“Wait, really?” Jennie took the pink flier out of her beat-up purse. January 9th 12pm. She’d conflated the date with the time.
The man took out a key ring and made to open the door. “Well, see you in a few hours.”
She didn’t have a few hours. She had to be at Lee’s by 10:00 a.m. And this could be her only chance to see behind the door before everything was cleared out. “Actually—I was just hoping to take a look. I heard this place has been locked up for a long time. Is it okay if I stick my head in now?”
“Last I checked, auctions are for buying not looking. I’m only here early to clean up.” He turned back to the door.
“What if I helped you clean? I bet it’s really dirty in there. You wouldn’t have to pay me,” she said, sounding more desperate than she’d intended.
He crossed his arms. “Why are you so curious about this room?”
“I like old things,” she said honestly. “And my friend Peter—he just passed away—I know he was excited to see what was in here.”
“Peter Altman?” The man sighed. “He was a good guy. And he did get to see in here—when the auctioneer came to take inventory, Peter helped him price things out. Took forever. He was very methodical. Opened every drawer, pulled every piece of equipment away from the walls.” He looked at Jennie and frowned. “I guess I could use a hand. It’s nasty in there. Your job is to get into the corners. My back isn’t what it used to be.”
Jennie nodded vigorously. “Deal.”
He unlocked the door and shuffled inside. Jennie followed, now brimming with anticipation. Very methodical. Opened every drawer. At the very least, Jennie now knew that the flier wasn’t in Peter’s pocket by chance—a spare scrap of paper, an erroneous thought. He’d had a particular interest in the space. Inside it was dark and smelled of dust and machine oil and some unplaceable musty funk. Click. The man pulled a string hanging from a green tin lampshade in the center of the ceiling and weak yellow light illuminated a filthy jeweler’s workshop, even more cramped than Carlos’s. Aside from a few footprints on the floor, which must have been left by Peter and the auctioneer, everything was covered in a thick layer of black Manhattan grime that had been sifting through cracks and air ducts for God knows how long. Jennie walked to the one small window and used her fist to rub a circle clean on the pane.
“Not much of a view,” she said, looking out at a brick air shaft studded with air-conditioning units and industrial vents jutting out from other workshops.
By way of answer, the janitor handed her a roll of paper towels, a black trash bag, and a bottle of cleaning spray. “I want to be done in an hour. Just do enough so people can see what’s in here. Nobody needs to eat off the floor.”
“Perfect. I have to be at work by then anyway.”
Jennie accepted the supplies and tried to keep her emotions in check. As she looked closer, she began to see all the fingerprints Pete had left behind in the dust. He must have been so excited to step into this room. It was like a walk-in time capsule. Though covered in dust, the shop was very well-kept. Or, at least, had been at one point. The back wall was lined floor-to-ceiling with wooden shelves stacked with chalky, grayish rectangles. Plaster molds for casting jewelry, Jennie knew from her grad school metalworking class. On a worktable, she saw antique versions of equipment she now recognized from her visits to Carlos’s shop: rolling mills, a polishing wheel, and rows of the blocky metal stamps known as dies that were used to punch out metal forms. There was one piece of equipment she didn’t know—it looked like a table saw with levered arms on either side. It was currently quilted in cobwebs. Perhaps this was the “diamond wheel and saw” mentioned in the flier? On the wall opposite the shelves, a filing cabinet and a jeweler’s workbench, with rows of pliers and rasps aligned in their holders, and a mounted magnifying glass also overtaken by cobwebs. Everything was neatly in its place. She opened the filing cabinet drawer with a rusty scrape that made the janitor scowl at her. An intact spider’s nest told her it had been empty for a long time. Nothing that seemed inherently “not safe.”
“Has there been a lot of interest in this sale?” she asked.
“That’s above my pay grade. You can start over there,” the janitor said, nodding to the jeweler’s workbench.
Jennie looked at the surface of the workbench and her stomach flipped unpleasantly: a gray shape, lumpy, angled, and unidentifiable. The remains of an unfortunate, trapped pigeon? But her squeamishness dissipated as she realized she was staring at not a mummified bird, but a dirty, crumpled rag. She tried to pick it up, but the pile collapsed into shreds. Cursing her indelicate touch, she moved her trash bag over to the edge of the bench so she could sweep the mess right in but stopped when she felt a solid shape.