"Don't."
She shuts her mouth.
"Three weeks they've had you in here." He's not loud. He's got the voice of a man who's been practicing in a bunkhouse at night. "Three weeks, and I've been feeding cows four hundred yards off and getting told no at the gate, and you know what I've been doing with it? I've been trying to figure out which part of my own sister I never met."
"Toby."
"Where were you when Daddy died?"
Her hands come down off wherever she had them and go to her sides.
"I was out of the country."
"Where?" He hasn't come one step farther into the room than those first two.
"I can't tell you that."
"Five years." Toby turns his hat around a half turn. "Five years, and that's still the fucking answer."
"Yes."
"They had him in that bunkhouse two days before anybody went in there." He says it without raising it one inch. "Two days, Neely. The hands thought he was sleeping in. And I drove all night, and I signed the paper, and I picked out the box, and I did the hymns, and I stood up at the front of a church in Sharp with sixteen people in it and no sister. For fuck’s sake, Mrs. Milling put her hand on my face afterward and said your sister couldn't get away, could she, and I said no, ma'am, she couldn't get away."
"Toby—"
"She knew. Everybody in that church knew. Those are people who've known us since you were in diapers, and every single one of them looked at me and decided not to say it out loud. And you know what? That was worse."
Nothing comes back out of her at all.
She takes one step sideways and puts her left hand up on the board wall and leaves it there, and whatever it is, it isn't nothing.
Toby stops talking.
He looks at her hand on that wall, and whatever's in him goes somewhere else for a second, and then it comes back, and it comes back worse.
"Sixty-one thousand, two hundred dollars."
She closes her eyes.
The tendons come up on the back of the hand she's got on that wall and they stay up.
"That's what's in it," he says. "You know that already. You've been looking at it. I can tell by your face you've been looking at it."
"Every month."
"I never spent a dollar of it." He's got the hat crushed down in both fists, and he doesn't know he's doing it.
"I know." She says it to her brother's boots.
"I tried to give it to him." Toby's voice goes finally, right there, and he keeps going through it, which is the worst part of all of this. "When he got sick. I had it in a cashier's check in my hand in that bunkhouse, and he asked me where it come from, and I told him you sent it. He set it on the bed between us and never mentioned it again, and he never took one dollar."
"Toby."
"He didn't say anything bad about you. Not one time, not to me." He's crying now and standing straight up in the middle of it. "He left it laying there. And I’ve thought about that every day for years, and I still don't know what he knew."
She's got her hand on that wall and her head down, and she doesn't make one sound.
Men have taken less than this in front of me and come apart louder.