Page 10 of The Prenup Clause

Page List

Font Size:

I’d forgotten she was coming over.

She stepped into the kitchen with a bottle of Pinot Noir under one arm and a brown paper bag from the Thai spot on Howell Mill. She was still in the post-shift glow of having changed out of scrubs into a sleeveless black dress, her honey-brown locs gathered into a high ponytail. Simone carried herself with the calm authority of somebody who spent forty hours a week running trauma triage at Grady Memorial; very little rattled her, and she rarely wasted energy on noise.

She smiled when she set the bag on the island, but the warmth dropped from her face the second she looked at me.

“What happened?”

“We need to talk.”

Her hands paused over the container of pad see ew. “That is never a phrase that leads to good news.”

“I know.” I pulled out a stool. “Nathan Whitaker didn’t file the final decree yet.”

I laid it out for her in plain English: the prenuptial agreement, the handwritten rider from years ago, the thirty-day mandatory cohabitation clause at the Blue Ridge cabin. I told her that Kembri’s attorney had requested a mutual waiver, and that I had refused to sign it.

Simone didn’t interrupt. She stood with her arms locked over her chest, her breathing slow and measured, watching my mouth move like she was charting symptoms on a monitor.

When I finished, the silence in the kitchen felt heavy enough to choke on.

“Let me make sure I’m hearing you correctly,” she said, her voice dropping into a dangerous, controlled register. “You had a waiver in front of you that would have finalized your divorce without you ever having to see Kembri Whitmore again. And you said no.”

“It’s not just a waiver, Simone. It’s an agreement we entered into before we got married.”

“Bullshit.” The word came out flat, stripped of patience. “A waiver is a choice. You chose to reject it. Which means you are choosing to spend the next thirty consecutive days living under the same roof with your wife in an isolated cabin three hours north of Atlanta.”

“It’s a legal obligation—”

“Don’t lawyer me, Chase.” Simone took a step toward me, the anger finally cracking through her professional composure. “When we started seeing each other eight months ago, you told me the marriage was over. I told you on our second date that I spent two years of my late twenties waiting on an ER guy who swore he was leaving his wife right up until I saw their anniversary photos on Facebook. I told you I would never be the woman on the side while a man negotiates his baggage.”

“You’re not on the side,” I said quietly.

“Then what the fuck am I, Chase?” Her voice rose, raw and sharp. “Because right now, you’re telling me you’re voluntarily packing your bags to play house with Kembri for a month. You keep calling it an obligation, but you and I both know what a reconciliation clause is. It’s designed to test if there’s still something left to save.”

“That’s not why I’m going.”

“Then why are you going? Give me one reason that makes sense.”

I opened my mouth to give her the same rehearsed answer I’d given David, but looking at Simone—at the exhaustion in her eyes, the hurt she was trying so hard to hide beneath her pride—the words felt hollow.

“Because I’m terrified that if I sign that waiver, I’ll spend the rest of my life wondering if we gave up because it was easy,” I said, the truth tasting bitter. “Over ten years ago, we swore that if things fell apart, we wouldn’t let pride or lawyers end us without looking each other in the eye in the place where we started. If I don’t see it through to the end, I won’t have closure. I’ll just have paperwork.”

“Closure is something you give yourself, Chase. It’s not something you go hunting for in a log cabin with your ex.”

“Simone—”

“No, listen to me.” She stepped closer, her jaw trembling slightly before she clamped down on it. “You’ve spent months taking comfort in my peace. You come over when work give you migraines. You let me cook for you, you sleep in my bed and tell me how refreshing it is to be with a woman who doesn’t demand chaos. And the entire time, you’ve kept one foot firmly planted in the past.”

Her words hit me squarely in the chest. Because she wasn’t wrong.

I had leaned on Simone’s stability. I had taken advantage of how graceful and undemanding she had been, all while giving her zero guarantees about what my life would look like once the dust settled.

“You’re right,” I admitted, my voice rough. “I’ve been selfish. But I’m not going to Blue Ridge to beg Kembri to stay. I’m going because I made a vow, and I need to close that chapter with a clean conscience before I can give anybody—including you—what they deserve.”

“That sounds noble as hell, Chase. But I need you to understand something.” She straightened her spine, pulling herself up to her full height. “I am not going to pretend this trip is harmless. I am not going to sit in my apartment for thirty days acting like everything is fine while you and Kembri figure out whether your marriage is salvageable. I need space. I need honesty. And I need you to know that what happens up there matters to me, whether you think it should or not.”

I looked at her, feeling the weight of what she was asking settle over me like a stone. Simone wasn’t issuing an ultimatum, but she was drawing a boundary—one I had no right to cross without consequences.

“I understand,” I said quietly.


Novels you may like ...