“But you did. And you kept doing it because it was easier than telling me the truth.”
I didn’t have a response to that.
She continued.
“I told you about Paul. I told you what it was like spending two years with a man who kept promising he was going to leave his wife and never did. I told you I wasn’t going to do that again. And you looked me in the eye and told me your situation was different.”
“It was different.”
“How? You’re married. You’re not living with her, but you’re not divorced either. And now you’re spending thirty days alone with her because you’re hoping she’ll change her mind.”
“Simone—”
“Don’t. I’ve heard enough.”
I heard her moving around, followed by the sound of a door closing.
When she spoke again, her voice was quieter.
“Do you know how humiliating this has been for me? My friends keep asking why I’m still dating a married man, and I’ve been defending you. Telling them you’re separated, the divorce is almost done, and things are complicated because of paperwork. All this time, the paperwork wasn’t the problem.”
“Simone, your friends don’t know everything about what happened between Kembri and me. It’s not their business anyway.”
“Fuck off!”
I closed my eyes.
Every time I tried to explain myself, I heard another version of what Kembri had been telling me for months. I’d made a decision that affected somebody else’s future and expected that person to understand why I’d done it.
With Kembri, I’d done something much worse.
I’d decided I didn’t want children, gotten a vasectomy, and concealed it because I couldn’t face what the truth might cost me. I’d let her keep talking about a future I’d already ruled out, then acted surprised when she couldn’t trust me afterward.
Now I’d insisted on honoring a clause that forced her to spend thirty nights with me before she could move forward.
And I’d expected Simone to be understanding while I did it.
I had spent years telling myself I was trying to keep everybody from getting hurt.
Looking at the situation plainly, I’d managed to hurt both women while protecting myself from decisions I didn’t want to face.
“Simone, you’re right to be angry,” I said.
“I’m past angry, Chase.”
“I know I haven’t been fair to you. I let you believe the clause was something I had to enforce when the truth is I wanted to enforce it. I let you think the divorce was moving forward when I was doing everything I could to delay it. And I accepted everything you gave me—your time, your patience, your feelings—while I kept hoping Kembri would come back.”
She didn’t respond immediately.
When she did, her voice was tight.
“So what am I supposed to do with that?”
“I don’t know. But you deserve better than what I’ve given you.”
“You’re damn right I do.”
I heard keys jingling on her end.