It took all my strength not to ask him about that. He’d tell me if he wanted me to know, and he’d been right—I wanted to finish what I was telling.
“It turned out it wasn’t as bad as I’d expected.”
“It never is.”
I started to agree then stopped myself. Experience had told me better. “No, sometimes it is. But this time it wasn’t, because I told…” I hesitated. I’d specifically left Hudson’s name out of the first story. He was a prominent businessman, someone who Edward would probably work with eventually if he hadn’t already, and I owed too much to Hudson to be the one to soil his name and turn his past against him.
So I left his name out again.
“I told the guy before I told my parents. The guy who I’d liked. The one who slept with my friend.”
“And you told him the baby was his father’s?”
I nodded. “He decided to claim the baby as his own, and that made telling Warren and Madge a whole hell of a lot easier because who the fuck cared what trouble Celia had made because now she was going to have a very wealthy baby! I mean, it hurt. It hurt knowing their reaction was only what it was because of what it gave them, but at least I didn’t have to get the tight-lipped, cold-shoulder treatment. So, you know. It was going to be okay.”
Edward sat forward, his finger up to stop me. “Hold on a moment—the guy who’d been an ass before now out of the blue decided to claim it was his?”
Up until then, he’d been almost soft—well, soft for Edward—but there was something distinctly biting in his tone.
“He wasn’t always an ass,” I said defensively, knowing that wasn’t the most important part of his question. “But, yes. He stood up for me. We told our parents together.”
It had been tense—all four of them and the two of us, half of us knowing that Hudson was definitely not the baby daddy, the other half ecstatic. My mother and his had immediately begun planning the wedding even though we’d made it perfectly clear we were not getting married. Then, while the others were talking about baby names, there’d been the moment between Jack and Hudson, a moment no one else saw but me. An eyebrow raise from the older, a terse statement from his son. This baby is mine now. I’m doing this, and it’s mine.
That had hurt in its own way. I’d believed Hudson had volunteered to be dad because he’d felt responsible for the position I was in. He also hadn’t wanted his mother to find out what his father had done, cheating on his wife with a woman half his age. But his words to Jack felt like they were only protecting my baby, his little brother or sister. Where did I belong in all of it?
“Why did he do that?”
I furrowed my brow, and since Edward couldn’t know what I’d been thinking, I didn’t know exactly what he was asking.
“Why did he choose to tie his whole life to yours?” His expression was as accusatory as his tone. “He didn’t even want to date you for a summer and now he wanted to be linked to you forever?”
“Uh...kind of harsh, don’t you think?” It was actually a valid question, though. One I hadn’t spent a lot of time thinking about when it had happened. I’d been too relieved and grateful to have him step up and save me.
And maybe I’d hoped it would turn into more. Eventually. If I was honest with myself.
Maybe letting Hudson pretend it was his wasn’t one of my finer moments.
“I only meant that it was a fast turnaround. He went from not caring about you to caring enough to make a terrible situation better for you. Why would he do that?” Edward had backed down, but his critical gaze continued to drill into me.
Why would he do that? “He didn’t want me ruining his parents’ marriage, that’s for sure. Though, honestly, I was not the reason there were problems in their marriage.”
“That’s a hell of a sacrifice to save a parents’ marriage.” He leaned forward, his elbows on his thighs, his hands clasped together. “He didn’t think it was his? You didn’t tell him the baby was his?”
“No. I didn’t sleep with him, remember?”
“There could have been a part of the story you’d left out.” He ignored the way I bristled at the accusation. “Was he in love with you after all?”
I could feel a muscle in my neck tick. “Were you listening last time? He knew sleeping with my friend would hurt me, and he didn’t care. He most certainly didn’t secretly love me.”
“Did you have something over him? Was it blackmail? Did you trick him?”
A cold chill ran down my spine. I hadn’t done any of those things, and the accusations had me seeing red.
But they were too close to things I had done to other people, and that made me feel guilt along with the rage. But how did he know? How could he possibly know?
I swallowed hard before responding. “I don’t know what you’re trying to get at, but no to all of that. He felt responsible, I think. Because he was responsible, in a way, and maybe I was the asshole because I let him do it, because I thought he owed me, but I didn’t trick him into it. It was all his own choice.”
We held each other’s stare for several breaths. Finally, he sat back into the sofa. “He stepped up. That’s admirable, I suppose.” There was no trace of apology on his features, but he was calm again. “I can’t imagine Hagen ever doing something like that.”