Page List

Font Size:

“Wren?” Her voice travels through the house, as high-pitched and excited as ever. “Ol’ Man Steve said he saw you drive through town not that long ago.”

Tilly Caldren has never knocked. I brace my hands on the counter and wait, not bothering to answer, and when she appears in the kitchen doorway, brownish-blonde hair, a wild swirly cloud around her face and a paper grocery bag clutched in her arms, my heart expands. She’s not changed since high school. Hell, she’s not changed since I saw her six months ago at June’s funeral. Tight jeans and a sweater wrap around her curves. Even though it’s Halloween, the sweater has reindeer and Santa hats dotting it, because Tilly has never cared about seasonal appropriateness. She sets the bag on the table, right on top of the Gold folder, and pulls me into a hug that smells like cinnamon and cold air and the floral soap she’s used since as far back as I can remember.

“You look like shit,” she murmurs into my hair.

I squeeze her back. “Thanks. You too.”

She scoffs at my comeback and pulls away, holding me at arm’s length, like she’s looking for something beneath the numbness I’ve masked all my grief with. Warm brown eyes move all over my face, doing that thing where they see about three layers deeper than I want them to. “How was the drive?”

“Long. Boring. Ohio is the least interesting state I’ve ever been to.”

“Isn’t that the truth?” She turns to the grocery bag and starts unloading items. A bottle of red wine clinks down on the table, followed by a loaf of bread, cheese, apples, and a container of what looks like soup. “I brought dinner. And before you say you’re not hungry, you’re eating. You’re too skinny.”

“I’m the same size I’ve always been,” I say, my hand pressing to my belly.

“Exactly my point,” Tilly says, stooping to pull a pot from the cabinet. She dumps the soup into it and turns on the burner with the confidence of someone who has cooked in this kitchen a hundred times. Tilly spent more nights here than at her own house our senior year, when things with her mom got bad. Aunt June never asked questions. She just made up the guest room bed and set an extra plate.

When I was here last, she filled me in on her latest love interest, Derek, even though we talk every Friday. Right now she rambles on about the kindergartener in her class who ate a glue stick this morning, about how Derek builds furniture and she discovered, has a dog named after a sandwich. I listen absently, and stir the soup, the relief of being known by someone who doesn’t need the backstory sweeping through me.

Coming here to pack up my past and put it all in storage is hard enough.

I fled this town and never planned to return. I opted out of walking on graduation day, packed my old Honda, and found a job in Chicago, where I could forget about this place and the boy with gentle hands and blue eyes.

“Did you see the farm on your way in?” she asks, slicing bread with Aunt June’s serrated knife. “The Dune’s place? They’ve got the maze up again for Halloween. It’s massive this year. Rides and stalls and everything. Gus says they planted an extra quarter acre of corn for it.”

The name does something to my heart. Gus. Noah’s father.

“I saw the lights,” I say. “They are hard to miss. I wanted to get here, so I didn’t drive past.”

I leave out that I didn’t want to.

Because Noah didn’t come to June’s funeral.

Chapter Two

Wren

“Noah’s been running the place since his dad took that nasty fall a few years back,” she says, her voice a tad too casual. Her eyes don’t move my way as she saws at the bread like it’s done her a personal wrong. The knife scrapes the cutting board, the sound grating down my spine. “He’s doing alright with all the responsibilities. He planted pumpkins this year and added a cider stand to the maze.”

“That’s nice,” I say, my tone flat. I know all this. She’s told me every detail about Noah over the last ten years, even when I told her I didn’t want the details.

He’s unmarried. Keeps to himself. He’s nice to everyone and everyone likes him. He’s helpful and volunteers at the local animal shelter.

He’s the classic definition of a serial killer and according to Tilly, way hotter than he was in high school.

She pauses, blade hovering over the bread, still not looking my way. Her next sentence is like a grenade rolled gently in my direction, ready to detonate. “He never dates anyone, you know. Not since… Well, you know.”

My lips purse together at the information. This isn’t the first time Tilly has mentioned Noah’s lack of dating. “That’s not really my business, Tilly.”

She mutters something then says, “I’m just saying.”

“Well, don’t.” I turn too quickly, reaching for the bowls, and my hand hits a mug. It drops to the counter, rolls drunkenly, and comes to rest by the toaster.

Tilly remains quiet for a heartbeat, but I feel her eyes on me. “How are you? Really?”

The question is too big for the kitchen. It contains too many haunted things, too many memories. The farmhouse and the papers on the table and the empty refrigerator and the blue ceramic vase on my mantel back home. It tastes like bonfire smoke and the cheap wine we drank out of red Solo cups in the empty fields at a forbidden party. It’s the exact shape of Noah’s mouth, who kissed me at eighteen with a desperation that felt almost painful. As painful as when I saw him making out with Debra Parker at prom. Of the static voice of a nurse telling me six months ago that Aunt June was gone and would I like to come collect her things?

I pour us wine, not meeting her eyes, and set the bowls down on the table, ignoring the pinch of my lungs and the realtor folder. “I’m fine,” I say, because it’s the only answer that fits all those thoughts.


Novels you may like ...