Everything inside me stops. For one horrible second, I genuinely wonder whether I’ve misunderstood her. Maybe there’s another Father, or talking symbolically? Maybe it’s some weird cult terminology I haven’t been told yet, because the alternative makes something vicious begin crawling its way up my spine. Catherine gasps, covering her mouth with her hand, as Don mutters, “Christ.”
I don’t move. I don’t trust myself to. “What do you mean you’re his wife?” I manage to push through clenched teeth.
Elizabeth looks confused by the question. “We’re married.”
There’s absolutely no emotion in the way she says it. No embarrassment, happiness, or sadness. She tells us she’s married the same way someone might tell me what day of the week it is. My jaw tightens so hard I think I crack a tooth. From the kitchen, something clatters; apparently Felix is listening—good—because I’m suddenly starting to understand why the giant FBI agent has spent the last several days looking like he’d personally fight God if God got too close to her.
“When did you marry him?” I ask her so carefully because I don’t know if I want to know the answer.
“On my twenty-first birthday.”
Some of the pressure loosens. Twenty-one… at least she wasn’t a child when he fucking married her, but then I remember the brief briefing we got about her, and the relief disappears. She may have been twenty-one when he called it a marriage, but she’d been trapped with him since she was six.
“What was the wedding like?” I ask, because apparently I’m a glutton for punishment.
Elizabeth’s face changes—it’s subtle, but it’s there. Her fingers stop moving against the blanket. “We went into the garden…” She pauses, staring down at her hands. “I was allowed outside because it was my birthday. Father asked me to walk with him, and he took me away from the others to a tree. He said God was our witness, so we didn’t need anyone else there. Then he asked if I promised to serve him and the All Father and remain devoted to them.”
I feel like I’m going to be sick. “What did you say?”
“I said yes.”
“Did you want to?”
Her head lifts, and the confusion on her face answers the question before she does. “I had to.”
Fuck. I press my tongue against the inside of my cheek because whatever is currently trying to come out of my mouth will not help her. Elizabeth continues as though she hasn’t just casually handed me another piece of information that makes me want to hunt this man down myself. “When we went back to the others. Father told them I was their sister now, then he told Harlow to prepare me and take me to the sacred room.”
Catherine inhales sharply, and I glance at her. Her eyes are already wet. Elizabeth notices too, and looks confused. “Why are you crying?”
“I’m okay, sweetheart,” Catherine says, although she very clearly isn’t. “You haven’t done anything wrong, and you haven’t upset me.”
Elizabeth looks back to me as she talks. I don’t know why she chooses me to continue with instead of Catherine or Don, but she does. “Harlow dressed me in a pretty white dress, then she told me she loved me before Father came in.”
I don’t know why, but I suddenly don’t want her to continue. Maybe it’s the way her voice cracked on the name of her friend, or the way her body is slowly curling into itself.
But she does.
“Father made Harlow leave. He said the teaching had prepared me and that I was ready to become his wife properly. Harlow was supposed to wait outside, but she came back in…” Elizabeth stops there, swallowing hard.
I don’t move… I don’t fucking breathe, but my hands curl into fists against my knees to stop myself from reaching for her. “Why?”
Elizabeth wipes at her face. “Because she heard me.” Every hair on my arms rises, and the room goes completely silent. Even Don doesn’t move. “She came into the room and told him to stop. Father told her to leave, but she wouldn’t. She pulled him away from me, and he hit her... I hurt him after that,” she admits.
“Good.”
Her eyes snap to mine, and Catherine hisses my name between her teeth. “Nope.” I shake my head. “I’m standing by that one.”
“But I wasn’t supposed to touch him,” she tells me, with the smallest amount of guilt laced in her voice.
I force myself to relax my hands because my nails are beginning to leave crescent marks in my palms. “I don’t care what you were supposed to do, Elizabeth. If somebody hurts someone you love, I’m not going to sit here and tell you that protecting them makes you bad. What happened next?” I ask her, because I know her story doesn’t end there.
She swallows. “He dragged Harlow downstairs, and I followed them. The other Sisters came out when they heard everything, and I begged them to help her… they didn’t. They just watched.” Her eyes drift toward nothing, and I watch as they find a small crack in the ceiling around the light fixture, and she traces it back and forth. “He was so angry. So, so angry because she interrupted the choosing. He shouted and screamed about how she ruined it, but she fought back… she always fought back… and he…”
She stops, and for the first time since she started talking, she seems genuinely unable to continue. I don’t push, and for once in my fucking life, I don’t make a joke. Catherine starts to move toward her, but I catch her eye and give her the smallest shake of my head. Not yet. Elizabeth hasn’t asked to be touched, and after watching Felix interact with her since we got here, apparently I’ve already adopted his permission-before-everything policy.
Elizabeth takes a slow, deep breath, then lets it out. “He killed her.”
Three words… that’s it, but I can hear the pain in her voice as she says them. They still feel like they’ve punched me straight through the center of my chest.