I lower it. She looks back at my face. "What does that mean?"
Tristan's entire face lights up again. "No," I say.
"But you just said she should ask questions,” he gloats
"Not that one."
Elizabeth's eyebrows rise. I realize my mistake approximately half a second too late. "You said I can question you."
Tristan makes a strangled sound beside Catherine. The little bastard is trying not to laugh. I look at Elizabeth, and she’s completely serious, but there's something new in her eyes… Something almost challenging, and fuck me, I think she's testing the rule. I lean back against the couch and sigh. "Yes, Elizabeth. You can question me."
"So what does that mean?"
Tristan loses the battle and starts laughing. I glare at him before looking back at her, and despite the fact that I know I'm about to have to explain to a woman rescued from a religious cult why I just gave Tristan the middle finger, I can't stop the smile from pulling at my mouth because she's questioning me, and I love it.
Tristan leans back in the chair, getting the conversation back on track. “You know, the first time I saw a supermarket, I thought it was some weird kind of warehouse.”
Elizabeth nods thoughtfully. “I have a memory of one from when I was young.”
“I could imagine,” he says to her, nodding his head.
“You could?”
“Not specifically,” he gestures at himself vaguely. “But I know what it’s like to come out of a cult and realize everyone else around me apparently got information about how the world works that you were never given. I can’t imagine how hard it is to have a vague memory of how that world works just to have it wiped away.”
Elizabeth stares at him for a moment and then nods again. I swear we’re all going to be bobbleheads by the end of the day, but that little nod makes my chest ache because he gets it. Not everything, because Tristan doesn’t seem to be a genius, and nobody could ever understand everything Elizabeth has lived through except Elizabeth, but he understands in a way that I can’t. I can explain what a supermarket is, take her to one, show her how money works, and explain why there are forty million different varieties of fucking cereal. But Tristan can understand why all those cereal options might be terrifying when your world before was simple.
“When I got out, I didn’t understand what menus were,” he tells her.
“Menus?”
“Restaurants.”
Her forehead scrunches as she tries to figure it out herself. “Is that the place where you choose your food?”
“Yeah, and there’s loads of different places to. Italian, indian, Chinese… pizza is my favorite though.”
“Why are there so many options?”
Tristan pauses, and I have to bite the inside of my cheek. Catherine isn’t nearly as successful as she laughs softly. There’s nothing cruel about it, and Elizabeth’s attention shifts to her. “That’s actually a very good question. Sometimes choosing what to eat is the worst part because there are so many choices.”
“There are too many choices. That’s the problem. Everyone tells you that freedom from the cult is amazing, but nobody ever warns you that freedom apparently means standing in front of a whole shelf covered in twenty types of toothpaste, wondering why teeth need this many options.”
Elizabeth looks back at him, and for several seconds, her face remains completely serious. Then… she smiles, like actually smiles. It’s small and uncertain, like she hasn’t used it enough to know if she’s doing it correctly, but it’s there.
Tristan smiles back at her, and Catherine looks like she’s approximately three seconds away from exploding from whatever maternal joy she’s trying unsuccessfully to contain—it genuinely looks like she’s planning their fucking wedding, so I decide to move to shift her attention from them. “So… coffee, anyone?”
Chapter Sixteen
TRISTAN
I’m still smiling like an idiot as Felix disappears into the kitchen, muttering about coffee and threatening to hurt all of us if anyone answers the door while he’s gone. Catherine waits until he’s out of earshot before leaning toward me and whispering that she likes him, gushing about how handsome he is, which is exactly the kind of information I could have gone the rest of my life without hearing. Don tells her to behave, but she just flips him off. “I am behaving. You never let me have any fun.”
I decide to ignore both my parents before they somehow make this even more embarrassing than it already is. Elizabeth is still sitting on the couch with the blanket wrapped around her, watching all three of us with the kind of concentration that makes me wonder how much of this she’s actually following. She doesn’t look uncomfortable, but I recognize the way her eyes move between us whenever someone speaks—she’s studying us instead of being a part of it—picking up the rules as she goes because she hasn’t learned them yet. I used to do the same thing.
Fuck, sometimes I still do.
When you've spent most of your life in a world where everything has rules, walking into one where people interrupt each other, make jokes, disagree without being punished, and apparently insult each other as a form of affection is fucking confusing. People don’t realize how many rules exist in normal conversation until nobody teaches them to you. She looks toward the kitchen where Felix disappeared before turning back to me. “Can I ask you something?”