“Not me what?”
“You weren’t the winner?”
“Nope.”
I couldn’t read the emotion behind his answer but there was something there. It almost sounded like resentment.
“You weren’t interested in the Frog Hogs?”
He shook his head against the pillow.
“This might be crass, but I have no interest in putting my dick in a woman who’s taken a friend. Which means I have less than zero interest in banging a chick who’s fucked most of my troop.”
His delivery might’ve been crass, but I had to agree with him. I wouldn’t have sex with a man who’d been with one of my friends. Multiple friends would be an absolute no-go.
Dutch cleared his throat and said, “But back then I was engaged.”
Engaged?
Dutch had been engaged.
Did that mean he’d been married?
“Engaged?”
Without thinking, my question just slipped out.
Dutch lay next to me perfectly still.
Silence stretched between us, and as it did, my stomach clutched, worried I’d overstepped.
“I shouldn’t have—”
“It was a long time ago.”
That might’ve been true, but his voice held an edge of anger that clearly conveyed he wasn’t over whatever had happened.
“I didn’t marry her.”
“Okay.”
“She died.”
I didn’t know what to say to that, especially because more anger had leaked in.
“Um…”
“It’s a cliché,” he started. “The bitch turned our relationship, and certainly her end, into a joke. An unoriginal story told by most guys who serve. But I didn’t even get a Dear John letter. I got a call my fiancée and brother had been in a car accident and neither had survived. Coming home from dinner. No, not dinner, a date.”
“Holy shit,” I murmured. “I don’t know what to say.”
“Nothing to say. The woman I’d spent six years with was fucking my brother behind my back while she was supposed to be planning our wedding. I don’t know exactly when it started but after they died, one of my brother’s friends told me he thought it was about a year. When I was packing up her shit, I found notes from my brother and suddenly a few things made sense. Jewelry I’d thought she’d bought for herself was actually from him. Weekend girls’ trips she went on were really weekend fuckfests with my brother. And it wasn’t a year, it was more like two. I don’t know why she didn’t just end it with me so she could be with my brother and I sure as fuck don’t know what was going to happen when our wedding day hit.”
Oh, yeah, I’d been right; there was anger and resentment, but more, there was bitterness. Not that I could blame him. I didn’t have a sister, and I’d never been engaged, but that didn’t mean I couldn’t understand the blow it would be to find out they were carrying on an affair. Not to mention the dying together after a date, leaving Dutch to mourn two people he loved who were betraying him.
“That’s fucked-up, Dutch.”
“It is that.”