Page 82 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

“That’s right, you cheeky bugger. Now, go sit, you lot. Dinner’s ready.” Harriet hustled us toward the dining table.

Clay walked the length of the table to the far end and held out his hand. “How you doing, Mr. D?”

“Same as usual.” They shook hands.

Clay dropped into the chair beside Donald, and I had a feeling he always sat there.

Harriet brought in the food. Lots of it. A roast beef, carved to perfection. Enough roast veggies to feed a soccer team and a pot of gravy that smelled so good my mouth salivated. I tried to remember the last time I’d had a roast dinner.

It came to me like an unpinned grenade. It had been Celeste’s eighteenth birthday dinner. Two nights before her actual birthday. She hadn’t wanted to spend her birthday night with her family; she’d wanted to be with her boyfriend. That decision had caused dozens of arguments between my parents.

I hated that I thought of it now, when the conversation around the table was so friendly and fun.

But fearing the conversation would soon turn to me, I directed a question at Clayton instead—an old interviewer’s trick. “So, how’d you come to having dinners here every Thursday, Clay?”

He helped himself to the potatoes. “We’ve been best friends since primary school. Why settle for one best mate when you can have three getting you into trouble?”

Everyone but Donald laughed, and it was the laugh of people who’d heard that response a hundred times and loved it every time.

The roast was incredible, and the family around the table were loud, warm, and fun, full of the easy language of people who’d loved each other their entire lives. It cracked open an ache in me I wasn’t braced for. I’d had this once, when Celeste was alive, when my family had still sat down together. I hadn’t known how badly I’d missed the uneventful noise of a happy family until I was sitting in the middle of one.

However, underneath the ache was the thing that took the air out of my lungs.

This family had lost a daughter, too. Yet, they still laughed. They still loved. They still set a full table and welcomed each other, and more people, too. They’d built a life on the other side of the worst thing that could have happened to them.

My family had shattered to pieces.

In a lull between the clinking of cutlery, Harriet turned to me, and when her eyes sparkled, I braced for a question I knew I wouldn’t want to answer.

“Whit tells me you’re working on an episode about that poor girl they found in the sand.”

My breath knotted, and her question landed heavily because she was also a mother who’d lost her own daughter.

Did she know I was reading through Charlotte’s case files? Oh, God. I should have asked Whit that before we arrived. Did she know how much I knew?

Worry gripped me as I met her gaze, hoping like hell that I didn’t ruin tonight’s dinner. “I am. I haven’t released it yet, though. Still a few things to check.” Somehow, I managed to keep the nerves out of my voice. “Her mother deserves closure, and I want to get it right for her.”

I felt Whit watching me from the side. I couldn’t see his face, couldn’t tell if I’d said the right thing or the wrong one.

“It matters so much … what you do,” Harriet said. Then a smile crossed her lips. “Our Charlotte would’ve loved your podcast. She was always so fierce about doing things properly. Do you remember that, boys? She’d give you all such a hard time if you did anything wrong.”

Charlotte had been missing for over twenty years, and yet Harriet had no trouble bringing her name up. No bitterness. No underlying anger. Only love. My parents could have had that, and instead every mention of Celeste had started a war.

“God, yeah,” Parker said. “Remember the time she⁠—”

Donald set down his knife and fork and stood. Without a word, he walked out of the dining room.

Nobody stopped him. Nobody called after him. Parker’s story just trailed off, and the rest of them kept eating, easy and unbothered. I had the feeling this happened often.

I looked at his empty chair, at the plate still piled with roast beef, and I understood him completely. Grief affects everyone differently.

But sitting there, in the middle of a family that had lost a daughter yet somehow stayed whole, something hardened in me. I was going to find Charlotte. I was going to give these wonderful people closure—something I was still chasing myself, answers that might have kept my family together.

Fear crept in right behind my promises because I’d promised closure before.

I’d promised to find Tegan for Michelle.

I’d promised Celeste that I’d find her killer, and I’d made that promise nearly every single day for eleven years.


Novels you may like ...