Page 77 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

Whit walked over and set a thick manila folder on the counter. His eyes met mine, filled with an aching sympathy. “The dental records and DNA came back from the lab. You were right, Angel. The body in the sand is Tegan Dawson.”

A hollow numbness washed over me.

Hearing the name out loud made reality crash through me like a wrecking ball.

I had talked to and interviewed Tegan’s mother, Michelle, many times. I had sat in Tegan’s bedroom, surrounded by her dusty netball trophies and her faded posters. I’d gone through the pockets of her clothes and photographed her trinkets and jewelry. I had looked Michelle in the eyes, held her trembling hands, and promised her that I would never give up the search for her missing daughter.

She hadn’t run away or started a new life as the police had assumed. While Michelle had wept herself to sleep, and the police had filed Tegan’s case away as a runaway, and while I had built a reputation on solving cold cases, she’d been right there.

The monstrous wrongness of it gutted me.

“Ten feet,” I choked out, my voice cracking. “How does an entire police force miss a body buried ten feet from a murder scene?”

“Sand is a difficult medium,” Whit said gently, though his voice lacked conviction. “Without cadaver dogs⁠—”

“No,” I interrupted, a dark, sickening realization taking root in my chest. “No, it doesn’t make sense. Unless ...” I looked at him as the seed of a terrifying theory planted itself in my mind. “Maybe the police who investigated Celeste’s death knew Tegan’s body was there all along.”

He pushed back, raising his hands. “There’s absolutely no evidence to support that, Angel. And we haven’t established that Bob Ackerman had any involvement in Celeste’s case. So no, I can’t support that idea.”

Whit relied on science and hard evidence for his work, yet despite his comment, I could see the wheels turning in his brilliant mind.

He pulled up a stool and sat across from me. “Let’s discuss the crime scene.” He swept his hand across the countertop like he was wiping a slate clean. “If we assume both girls died on the same night ... why bury one girl and leave the other staged on the beach?”

My brain hurt as I tried to slot those two pieces of the puzzle together. I pulled over my notepad and pen, wrote the question down and circled it twice.

Suddenly, a solution to that puzzle shifted into place. “I have an idea. Okay, here’s what we know,” I said. “Celeste and her boyfriend Tyson got home from her birthday dinner at 11:30.”

I wrote the time on the notepad and scribbled home from dinner beside it.

“Celeste said she didn’t want her birthday to end and wanted to go for a walk on the beach.”

“And her boyfriend didn’t go with her.” Anger flashed across Whit’s face.

“Yeah. The bastard went to bed instead.” I tapped my pen against the notepad. “That beach is a known surfers’ hotspot. They get out there at first light, often even before sunrise when the water is like glass.”

“She died on the twenty-eighth of November.” He reached for his laptop and opened the lid. “I wonder what time sunrise was?”

“Four forty-four a.m.,” I said. “I checked ages ago. I wanted to know how long Celeste was lying out there in the dark. A surfer found her at five-ten.”

Whit slowly closed the laptop and looked at me, his eyes softening with a heavy sorrow that made me want to look away. He didn’t say anything. He didn’t need to. He just let the weight of my grief rest between us for a moment. God knew we both had had our share of that.

“So,” he said, clearing his throat. “What’s this idea you had?”

“Right. Well, maybe the killer was in the middle of burying Tegan when Celeste stumbled upon him.” I swallowed hard, the mental image threatening to make me sick. “Oh, God. She was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. It makes sense, doesn’t it? He killed Celeste because she saw him.” My voice trembled as my thoughts locked onto that idea. “But he ran out of time to bury her. The sun was coming up. The surfers were arriving.”

“And burying a body in sand is much harder than in soil,” Whit added. “The sand keeps shifting, dry grains constantly falling back into the pit as you dig.”

“So, he staged Celeste’s body instead.” I stared at the counter, fighting the rage searing through my veins.

“When Celeste’s body was found by a surfer, the police focused entirely on her,” Whit said. “There was no obvious reason for them to believe there was more than one victim.”

“And because of the way that bastard arranged her body, the police had already made up their minds that it was some fucking sex act gone wrong.”

Whit shook his head, his expression softening. “I’m so sorry that happened.”

I swallowed the lump in my throat. “I hated that the media painted Celeste as someone she wasn’t. She was sweet. Innocent. She wouldn’t have been into rough, dangerous sex. It never made sense to me. But the police were so sure. They built their entire case around it. They built it around ...”

I froze. The breath died in my throat.


Novels you may like ...