Page 69 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

So, I topped off our wine glasses and carried them to the living area. I sank into his deep, comfortable sofa, stretched my legs out, and watched him move about the kitchen. That was another first for me—a man cleaning up after me while I sat back and relaxed.

In the last forty-eight hours, I’d had so many firsts it was no wonder my head was spinning.

Whit finished wiping down the counters, grabbed the wine bottle, and walked over to join me. He sat on the opposite end of the couch, yet he was still close enough that I could smell his divine cologne. He took a sip of his red wine, then set his glass down on the coffee table. “I keep thinking about what you said earlier.” He turned his head to look at me. “About starting with the obvious connections that are missing.”

I shifted slightly to face him better. “Lola’s father?”

“Exactly. If he left when Lola was two or three, he’d been gone for over a decade by the time Charlotte disappeared. But did anyone actually check whether he’d tried to contact Lola around that time, or if he was in town?” Whit shook his head. “I can’t even recall the police report mentioning him. It lists him as estranged, and whereabouts unknown. So now I’m wondering if they even tried to look for him.”

My detective brain, briefly asleep under the influence of carbs and wine, snapped wide awake. “They didn’t because they were too busy focusing on the local teenagers, or assuming Charlotte was a runaway. A missing father is a classic blind spot. If he wanted to get to Lola, or if he was watching Lola ... Charlotte was always with her. They did everything together. Or maybe he thought Charlotte was Lola.”

Whit’s eyes darkened with sharp intensity. “Do you feel like doing some more research?”

“Absolutely.” I pushed forward on the sofa.

“Stay there,” Whit said, standing up. “I’ll bring some boxes down.”

He marched back down the stairs, carrying three cardboard boxes, and set them down on the coffee table with a dull thud. “I have no idea if we’ll find his details in these,” he admitted, rubbing his palms together. “I just know these boxes haven’t been looked at in a very long time.”

We each chose a box, spreading the contents across the coffee table and spilling them onto the floor rug.

The first folder I pulled out contained witness statements from the night and the next day after the party. Some had been taken by Bob Ackerman. Reading them now, knowing what a corrupt, self-serving bastard Ackerman was, made me suspicious of every single sentence.

The next folder contained heaps of glossy prints—a visual display of Charlotte’s life from a young child to a teenage girl, always smiling and showing off for the family.

I flicked through them, but nothing stood out that was worth listing in my notebook.

Near the bottom of my box, I removed another photo. This one was of the four Callahan siblings. Three fit-looking teenage brothers and their little sister, laughing at the camera, their arms slung over one another’s shoulders. For a second, Charlotte stopped being a name in a case file. She was just a young girl, a loved sister, who had gone to a birthday party and never come home. I looked at her bright eyes, then looked up at Whit, seeing the ghost of that same boy in the lines of his face.

I turned the photograph so he could see it. “Look at the four of you.”

He leaned in, and the couch got a lot smaller than it had been thirty seconds earlier. His shoulder pressed against mine. I smelled his cologne, and every clever thing I’d been about to say went straight out of my head.

“Charlotte hated that shirt.” He rolled his eyes. “Told me it made me look like a geography teacher.”

“She wasn’t wrong.”

He laughed and turned his head, and he was so close I could see the darker ring around his irises. His gaze dropped to my mouth and stayed there.

Neither of us moved.

For years, I’d kept every living soul at arm’s length, and this man had nudged his way inside my guard in two days.

He lifted his hand. His fingers brushed my jaw.

Another missing girl, Tegan Dawson, swept into my thoughts like she’d been waiting out in the hall.

I don’t know why. Maybe it was Charlotte’s face in that photograph, another girl who’d gone to a party and never come home. Tegan arrived in my thoughts sharp and cold and completely uninvited, the way the dead always did with me.

I pulled back.

“Sorry. Sorry, I ...” he blurted.

“No. No. It’s not that.” I set the photo down between us and cleared my throat. “Have you ever heard of Tegan Dawson?”

Whit frowned, his fingers pausing on the edge of the photo. “No. The name doesn’t ring a bell. Why?”

“She was a seventeen-year-old girl who vanished the same night my sister was murdered.” I leaned forward, picked up my wine glass but didn’t drink, and let my mind race.


Novels you may like ...