Page 139 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

Angel was watching me through the window. I slid open the glass door and motioned for her to join me.

“What is it?” she asked, frowning.

“We’ve identified the girl from under the barrel.”

Her hand flew to her mouth. “You have?”

“Katrina Sutton.”

“Oh.” She blinked. “That’s … that’s good. How?”

“Her aunt came forward after hearing your podcast. The DNA results arrived this morning.” I held up my phone. “I’m about to call her. Do you want to be here?”

“Oh. Wow.” Confusion crossed her face, followed by the first flicker of light I’d seen in days. “Yes. Okay.”

We sat together on the bench, and I dialed.

The call was answered on the second ring.

“Hello?”

The voice was thin and frail with age.

“Mrs. Whelan? My name is Whitney Callahan. I’m the forensic pathologist who looked after your niece, Katrina.” I kept my voice gentle, the way I’d learned to do after years of having the worst conversations imaginable.

A sound came down the line, half breath and half sob. “Thank you for calling me. Can you tell me what happened to Katrina?”

“I can. Angel Tomkins is here with me.”

“The lady from the podcast?”

“Hello, Nancy,” Angel said softly.

“Oh, hello. It was your podcast that made me wonder if that poor girl—the one everyone called …”

“Kat,” Angel said gently.

“Yes. Kat. I wondered if my Katrina had finally been found after all these years.” Nancy’s voice trembled. “I thought I’d go to my grave without knowing what happened to her.”

“I understand you’ve been waiting a long time,” I said.

“Most of my life.”

“I can tell you what we know so far, but there are still details we’re working to establish.”

“I understand.”

With Angel pressed against my side, I told an elderly woman in Brisbane the truth about the niece she had never stopped hoping to find. I didn’t hide the difficult parts from her. She had waited fifty years for answers, and I gave them to her as gently as I could.

Then Nancy told us her side.

She told us about Katrina as a girl, about the last time she’d seen her, and about all the assumptions the family had made after she disappeared. She told us a part of the story that was every bit as gut-wrenching as the one I’d told her.

Beside me, Angel’s breath caught more than once.

Before we ended the call, Angel asked if Nancy would let her interview her for another podcast—one that would give Katrina back her life, not only her name.

“Yes. Of course, I will.” Nancy’s answer was so bright it caught beneath my ribs.


Novels you may like ...