Not because the desire disappeared.
Because she told him not to.
“It shouldn’t have taken her leaving for you to understand,” I say.
“No.”
Another admission.
The fight I carried up the hill begins losing its shape. I’m still furious, but there is nowhere to direct it when he refuses to defend the indefensible.
I look at the remnants of breakfast between us.
“Did you know she would choose both of us?”
Dad’s expression closes. “No.”
“What would you have done if you had?”
“Kept you away from her.”
The honesty lands like a slap.
“At least you admit it.”
“You asked.”
“You would have hurt us both.”
“It would have prevented this.”
He gestures between us as though our current situation is an illness.
“Holly doesn’t think there is anything to prevent.”
“Holly has known me for one day.”
“And she still chose you.”
His eyes sharpen.
I lean forwards. “That’s what you keep refusing to understand. You blame me for being there first as though I tricked her into caring about me. Then you blame the bond for her wanting you. She chose us both after she knew enough to walk away.”
“She didn’t know everything at that point.”
“She knows enough now to be furious.”
“Enough to decide whether she can forgive me or not.”
The certainty has gone from his voice.
I study him carefully. “You’re afraid she won’t.”
Dad’s gaze turns glacial. “Be careful.”
“There it is.”
“What?”