I nodded my assent. He didn’t tell me what it was, but the deep ruby purple color told me it was a rich wine. My tongue tingled in anticipation. There were few things I had enjoyed from my parents’ world. Remarkable wines topped that short list. Just thinking of my parents triggered an ingrained response, raising my fingertips toward my mouth. Before I could nibble the nonexistent nails, Cas gently took my hand in his.
“Sabrina, you don’t have to be anxious. Please, just let me care for you while I explain some things that will hopefully shed light on me, Tyson, and our issues with each other.”
Color me intrigued. “Of course.”
He laid my hand in my lap and took his seat, pouring himself a generous amount of wine and taking a large gulp before sitting back. Lief bustled in with a salad, but I’d lost interest in the food, much more hungry for answers.
“You and I spent our summers together until I was fifteen. So let me catch you up on the eleven and a half years since your last visit.”
I took a large swig from my glass and gave him my undivided attention.
“High school was a nightmare those first few years. Tyson was very popular, a star athlete and with his father being sheriff, most of the kids wanted Tyson as a friend. They probably hoped to get out of parking tickets and be let off easy, if caught with alcohol in their trucks.”
I took a deep drink of the wine. “I’m sorry to interrupt, but you’re telling me Tyson’s father was the sheriff, too?"
Cas snorted, an unpleasant sound that matched his humorless smirk. “Yes, and his father before him, and his father before him. Basically, Tyson’s family has been in law enforcement of some type since the town came to be. Houndstooth is one of the founding families, and Midland’s first ever sheriff was a Houndstooth. That’s public knowledge.”
Maybe it was public, but I hadn’t known about the Houndstooth legacy.
“Anyway, Tyson had a posse of followers. I wouldn’t call them friends per se. More like enforcers. Soldiers he commanded, who carried out his orders and tried to garner his favor.
In our sophomore year, I started dating Ronnie, you may know her mother. She runs the local library, Ruby Redd.”
I didn’t know what her daughter looked like, but Ruby was a very attractive woman. I could imagine a younger version of her with long hair, cherry red lips, and stunning features hanging on Cas’s arm. I didn’t like that image, or the sensation it caused tightening my chest. I quickly banished it and focused on the story Cas was telling.
“Tyson always flirted with Ronnie. He made it his personal mission to insinuate himself in our relationship at every opportunity, running interference.”
“Really? How would he run interference?” Although Tyson hadn’t really done that with Cas and me, it was definitely in the realm of possibility. I heard enough almost-comments, insinuations, and seen enough side eyes from the sheriff to know without doubt he had an interest in me and Cas. No, he hadn’t said anything directly negative, but Sheriff Houndstooth always seemed to be around when I was out of sorts with ‘The Monster of Midland’.
“At school it was simple things. He’d blame me or Ronnie for something so one of us would get detention. That was the least harmful of the things he did. One time, when I’d taken Ronnie to a movie in the next town over, we exited to find the tires of my car slashed. Having to get a tow made both of us late coming back. She was grounded and I was…well, you know what my father was like. I was bedridden for a few days and that was the least of my problems.”
I shuddered, remembering how abusive Cas’s father had been. Although he’d mentioned that his parents had died in a car crash, he’d also said that despite no evidence being found, he suspected foul play. Would Cas...No! Kill his own parents? Despite the resentment he had stored behind his facade for his father, Cas wasn’t a murderer. If he had been guilty, why would he mention something that couldn’t be proven? No, if it was foul play, it wasn’t Cas who’d done it.
“Things came to a head in our senior year,” he continued. “Tyson made it known around school that he was going to steal Ronnie from me. I confronted him and we fought. When the principal found us, Tyson played the victim, yet again. I was detained after school. It was the day of All Hallows Eve and Ronnie and I had plans that evening.”
A bad feeling stole over me, and I reached for my wine glass, emptying it in one big gulp. An instant light buzz relaxed me. Cas followed suit and then filled both our glasses half way. When I’d stayed here with him before, he would make me eat before giving me more wine. Apparently, I wasn’t the only one who needed some liquid courage.
“When I came out of detention and rounded the corner toward the school exit, I saw Tyson leaving the girl’s bathroom. He was tucking in his shirt. Something told me to hold back and see what was happening, so I remained hidden in the corner. A minute later, Ronnie came out of the bathroom, righting her clothing.
I lost my shit, demanding she tell me what happened. She tearfully told me that, after school, she had a meeting with a teacher and had stayed behind after her last class. She said as she was leaving, Tyson ambushed her and, according to her, dragged her into the girl’s bathroom where he raped her.”
Holy shit! I reached for my glass with shaking hands, imagining that same beautiful girl I’d pictured, suffering every woman’s worst nightmare. “Are you fucking kidding me? How is the bastard not rotting in jail right now, instead of running it?”
“No, I’m not kidding. But there is more to this story.”
I spluttered my wine all over my salad. “I’m sorry, what do you mean by ‘more to the story’?”
Cas leaned back in his chair, his fingers rumpling the cloth napkin on the table in front of him. “Later that same night, I went to confront Tyson. When I found him, I attacked him and I was winning, until someone shouted ‘fire!’ That stopped our battle long enough to see the fairground building on fire. Ronnie was in there. I knew she was because we’d planned to meet up there.
I ran inside the building shouting her name frantically. So many times I called out for her, desperate to find her, looking everywhere, but she never called back to me.
Part of the roof collapsed, trapping me inside. If the fire department hadn’t arrived when it did,” he indicated his scars, “my scarring would be much worse. Or I wouldn’t be here at all.
I don’t remember much after the roof collapsed. I woke up in a hospital bed with tubes attached to me and half my body wrapped in white bandages. It was the first and only time my parents showed any genuine concern for me. When they were assured I’d live, they left.
Being stuck in that hospital bed alone gave me plenty of time to think about what had happened. Plenty of time to grieve Ronnie. I knew she was dead. Otherwise, she would have called out to me in that building. I’d been certain, but oh, how wrong I was.”
It was ironic that I’d tried so hard to get this man to laugh and, when he finally did, it was with a bitterness so deep, it slammed into my heart with the force of a shotgun.