Heart thumping faster, I remind myself that it wouldn’t be the first time I’m mistaken. I spend so much time alone these days that when I’m in public sometimes I see him everywhere.
I abandon the remaining items on my list, pay, and hurry outside to load the groceries into my car.
The road empties after the final gas station. I check my mirror every so often, but no vehicle follows for longer than a mile.
The first raindrop splatters against my windshield.
By the time I reach the turn toward my property, I have explained everything. The woman stirred up memories. The freezer reflection belonged to another shopper. Half the town owns a black coat.
Halloween is close, and my mind is playing tricks.
Nothing—and, most importantly, nobody—followed me home.
* * *
It’s outright drizzling when I pull into the driveway of my house.
I load both arms with groceries, wedging the bread between the crook in my elbow and balancing the eggs against my chest. The plastic handles from the bags start to slip from my fingers, but I manage to make it to the door in time.
Unlocking both deadbolts, I stumble inside to the warning chirps from the alarm. I promptly punch in the code and then haul everything into the kitchen. The panel confirms nobody entered while I was gone.
I return to the car for the case of water.
A jack-o’-lantern sits beside the welcome mat.
It’s no larger than a cantaloupe, its orange skin rough and lumpy. One triangular eye sits higher than the other, the narrow slit that’s the nose in between. Its jagged mouth stretches wide, crowded with square teeth that give the pumpkin a menacing grin.
The pumpkin wasn’t here when I left. Delivery drivers use the metal box beside the road, exactly as my instructions state.
My muddy footprints dirty the dry porch boards, but no second pair exists anywhere on this porch. Whoever placed the pumpkin approached before the rain or took care not to leave a mark.
I pick it up.
A Post-it Note has been folded under the pumpkin. Five words are written in the center:
It’s been 5 long years.
The note trembles between my fingers, blurring the ink, so I pin it against the pumpkin and read it again.
I search the road to the bend where the trees block it from view. There’s no taillights retreating through the branches or any figure creeping between the wet trunks. The nearest occupied house is far enough away that its roof can’t be seen from mine.
The message refers to the anniversary I’ve never discussed in this town.
Only one person would count the years this way, but he can’t be hiding beyond those trees after all this time.
He can’t have followed me to this secluded location just for his revenge. Just so he could keep the promise he made that night.
…could he?
CHAPTER 3
ALAIA
I almost miss Mr. Benson’s driveway because I’m watching the empty road behind me instead of the rusted mailbox ahead.
My tires bite into wet gravel when I brake, and I turn between two crooked fence posts.
Mr. Benson’s house sits at the end of the drive, a low brick ranch with aluminum awnings and gutters stained black under the seams.