Page 130 of Plug and Claim

“So tight,” he murmured, pushing his fingers in and out of her before moving them to her asshole. “But not as tight as your ass.” He pushed his fingers in, one at a time, watching Kira shudder under him. “Remember this moment when you’re with Mark, Kira. No matter how it feels to have your virginity taken, nothing will ever compare to what I’m about to do to you.” He leant over her, stroking himself as he sucked on her earlobe. “No one will ever fuck you like I do. Your hymen might still be intact after this, but you sure as hell won’t feel like a virgin once I’m done with you.”

“Please, Nathaniel.”

“Please what?” he asked, undoing his belt and trousers and pulling out his cock, dipping the head into her dripping pussy. Her folds glistened in the dim light like the diamonds on display in the cabinets, and as he pulled the head of his cock back out, it glistened too.

“I don’t want to be punished.”

“That’s not true,” he whispered, dipping the head of his cock into her again, pushing her apart. She felt so good, but it was excruciating to hold back from pushing it into her fully. In one swift moment, he could claim her maidenhead, and feel her blood coat him, just as it should. “I think you like being punished. And you will never forget what I’m about to do to your ass. With his cock head embedded in her folds, he leant forward so he could see her face, taking care not to penetrate her further. “Speechless?”

She swallowed nervously. “You said it would hurt.”

“It will hurt,” he promised, petting her head the way she liked it to reassure her. “But it’s nothing you can’t handle. The pleasure, I promise, will be worth the discomfort.”

Kira nodded, but her voice nearly broke as she whispered, “I’m scared.”

He leant closer, sliding another tantalising inch into her.

Fuckkk. Careful.

He cupped her face with one hand and kissed her forehead. “I know. But I’m here with you. I’ll never let anything bad happen to you.”

The words slipped out before he could stop them. He meant them—he wanted to protect her and shield her from the world’s terrors—but the words contradicted the real reason he’d gone to her cottage in the first place.

“You are the bad thing that’s happened to me,” Kira cried, startling him.

“Yes,” he admitted thoughtfully, resisting the urge to push his cock in another inch, even though it was killing him, his balls aching as if they were about to explode. “Maybe I am.”

Maybe I should stop this.

Doubt crept into his mind, but then Kira nodded, resigning herself to what was about to happen.

Blinding lust took over, and it was all he could do to pull out of her, sliding out of her delicious cunt.

“Ready, pet?” he asked, even though there was no way she could possibly be ready for his cock. At least a plug, once inserted, no longer pushed on her sphincter, but the length and thickness of his cock was another matter entirely. Her sphincter would be stretched wide the entire time he was inside her, rubbing her all along his shaft, and when he moved into her, she would scream.

The prospect excited him to no end.

“I’m ready,” she told him, her voice stronger than it was before.

She trusts me.

It was a precious thing, one that he would cherish. One that he did not deserve. But that wouldn’t stop him from using her now.

He could see her face reflected in a silver plate behind the table. Their gazes met.

“Eyes on me. Watch what I do to you, pet. Witness your master fuck your ass for the first time.”

He pushed the head of his cock against her asshole. It met so much resistance that it was like hitting a wall.

“Fuck,” they cried out together.

He pushed harder, and Kira’s face contorted as her asshole yielded the tip of his cock.

“You are so fucking tight,” he growled, pushing his cock forward. It was an impenetrable wall, but he would not stop until he’d penetrated it.

Kira gasped as he forced his cock into her, this time embedding the broad head, the largest part of him, into her sphincter.

“It’s too big,” she cried.