Page 80 of For I Have Sinned

“How the hell did that even happen?” Amelia pokes for further details.

For the next few minutes to explain to them what happened in the booth and the events that led up to it. Alex’s confession and how his words caused me to go into his side of the booth to begin with.

“That is so hot.” Vince states. “And then something happened in his office?”

“Yeah.” I scratch at the back of my neck. “It was after my parents visited, and yes, both of them came today, and I’ll get into that later, but he asked to see me in his office after. We talked about what happened in the confessional and mutually decided that we wanted to keep hooking up.”

“Again, hot,” Vince says immediately once I finish talking.

“What was hot was that he let me tell him what to do. Then there was the fact that he buried his face and dick between my legs.”

“You had sex with a priest!?” Amelia about combusts.

“No!” I shout and then lower my voice. “We didn’t have sex. The head priest was in the hall, so it got cut short, but he still shoved himself inside me for a brief second and said it was to prepare me for when he does fuck me because my god, he is huge.”

“I might have to retire this word from my dictionary, but that’s fucking hot. And he is huge? How big are we talking?”

“Big. And he is also thicker than I’ve ever seen. I about died when he just rammed himself in there and didn’t give me time to prepare.”

“Death by dick.” Vince sighs. “What a way to go.”

“I can’t believe you’re hooking up with a priest.” Amelia chimes in.

“Me neither. After Alex, I don’t know how I’ll ever go back to another man.”

“What if you just live in the convent? That way, you never have to leave him,” Vince suggests it as a joke.

“I’m not trying to stay here longer than I have to.”

“Do you think he would leave the convent?” Amelia asks.

I roll my eyes. “You guys, I’m hooking up with the man. It’s not like we are about to ride off into the sunset togeth⁠—

“Who are you talking to?

I pause mid-sentence when I hear Alex’s voice from behind, and I immediately spin around on the bed to face him, but then my body stiffens when I see the frustration in his eyes, and all the noise around me fades as my brain begins to scramble.

How much did he hear?

How long was he standing out there?

I begin to feel uneasy when I think back to this morning, the memory of our pinky promise that I insisted on to solidify our agreement to not tell a soul…

A promise I broke in the same day I made it.

“No one,” I lie and then curse in my head when I hear Amelia and Vince through the phone. I squeeze it in my hand, wishing it would snap in half to get them to shut up.

“What did I say about talking on the phone again?”

“Not to do it,” I respond softly, fear of making him disappointed rolls through my body.

Alex hums and walks towards me calmly, which does not match the hardened expression on his face. His arm reaches around me and snatches the phone out of my hand, without wasting a second, he slams the phone shut.

Chapter 26

Father Alexander

With the phone in my hand, I stare down at Celine and try to keep my composure. Hearing her talking on the phone, saying my name, changes my original plans for coming in here. I wanted to see her to tell her that I’ll be leaving to visit my mom and then fuck her, but that isn’t going to happen.