Page 33 of My Weakness

“I-I don’t think you’d fit. I’ve never…and you’d be the first.” Relief floods me, the thought of someone having her that intimately would have gutted me. “River, you’re huge,” she whispers in fear. I can’t deny her words are a serious boost to my ego.

“You can take me. I’ll get you ready before you take my cock in that tight virgin hole.” Her pupils dilate at my words, and I know I’ve got her.

Tonight, I’m going to fill her ass with my cum.

***

She’s naked on the bed, face pressed into the mattress, ass up on display for me.

“You’re doing so well for me, baby. It feels good, doesn’t it?”

“Yes,” she hisses as two of my fingers slide deep in her untouched hole.

I’ve been prepping her for the last half-hour. She’s come on my fingers and tongue twice already, once from me playing with her cunt and once from ass play alone. I’m going to fucking explode when I get my cock inside her, I don’t think I’ve ever been so turned on in my life.

“I need you to take a third for me, pipsqueak. We get three fingers inside you, and you should be able to take my cock.” I groan as her ass clenches around my fingers at my words — she’s so fucking into this.

I squeeze a dollop of lube onto her asshole and make sure my other finger is nice and coated before I gradually push it inside to join the other two. She presses her face into the mattress more firmly and pushes back onto my hand, causing all three of my fingers to slide deep inside her.

“Oh, you good girl,” I praise her as I stroke up and down her spine with my free hand. “Such a pretty little slut for me, aren’t you?”

“Only for you,” she mutters into the covers.

“You’re damn right, pipsqueak, only ever for me. No one else will ever touch you again.”

“Please, River, I want your cock.” My cock, which was already leaking pre-cum, gushes at her words.

“Yeah, baby, you want my cock in your ass?”

“Yes, yes, yes,” she chants.

I pull my fingers from her and give her ass a light little spank.

“Get on your back at the edge of the bed. I want to see the look on your face when I take your ass for the first time.”

I grab the bottle of lube and cover my cock in the liquid, hoping to cause her as little discomfort as possible during this. I notch the head of my cock at that tight ring of muscle and raise my eyes back to hers before I push inside her.

“Eyes on me, baby. I need you to relax and look at me, only me.”

She bites her lip as I push through her resistance and clench my teeth at the unbelievable pleasure that assaults me.

“Fuck, that’s it,” I groan as the first couple of inches slide inside her.

I’m about half-way when I see it; the flash of pain in her eyes, her teeth pressing down a little bit harder on her lip. I pause and give her time to adjust to the size of me. She’s right, I’m not the cock you want for your first time, but she’s never getting anyone else’s, so it’s mine she’s got to deal with.

“Rub your clit for me, pipsqueak, get yourself off while I give you the rest of me.” Her fingers eagerly seek out that tight bundle of nerves and rub it in small circles. “Tell me when you’re close.”

I can already feel her walls tightening around me, but I won’t give her the rest of my cock until she’s mid-orgasm. Her eyes are glazed in pleasure, and I know it won’t be long before she’s coming for me.

“River,” she cries. “I’m going to come.”

“That’s it, scream my name as you come for me. Let everyone know who gets to fuck you.” My words are all she needed to push her over the edge, and she sobs my name as her release rushes through her.

I push inside her, until my hips rest against her ass cheeks and she’s taken every single inch of me.

“Oh God,” she gasps through her orgasm.

“Fuck, baby, you feel so good. I won’t last long with how fucking amazing you feel.”