Finn slips his hand over her hip to circle her clit. She screams her release as she squeezes so tight around us. Finn’s cock jerks against mine as her pussy milks me, making it impossible to hold back any longer. Sparks gather at the base of my spine and my balls tighten. I manage a few more thrusts before I drive in deep, filling her with my cum.
“That’s it, trouble, swallow Dante down, then turn to take me in your mouth.”
If I weren’t still shivering from coming so hard inside her, I’d want to watch her with Wyatt, but fuck, I think I’m done. I release her legs and pinch her clit to see if I can make her have another orgasm.
She tightens around me again and moans. It’s almost painful on my cock.
After I pull out, I fall to the floor next to her in time to see her sucking on Wyatt’s cock as he comes down her throat. Fuck. My half-mast dick twitches, but I’m done. Fuck.
Sara turns those pale green eyes on me with a dazed smile, and my cock surges to salute her fully. Fuck. This woman is everything.
“Come on, trouble.” Wyatt lifts her off Finn and takes her into the bathroom to clean her up.
Dante offers me his hand and I clasp his wrist to let him help me to my feet before he does the same for Finn.
“What’s the plan for the sleeping arrangement? Boxers, no boxers, head to foot? Sorry, I don’t do a lot of sleepovers. I don’t know what the protocol is.” I smirk and run my hand over the back of my hair.
Dante hands me a wet washcloth. His gaze strays to the open door of his bathroom. Wyatt’s kissing the shit out of Sara while she wraps herself around him.
“It’s up to her.” Dante shrugs. “We’ve never really done this either. Boxers seem reasonable though.”
I glance around to find mine. By the time I have them on, Sara steps up to me, completely naked like the goddess she is, and wraps her arms around my waist. Her head rests against my beating heart. It thumps a little louder for her attention.
“Good night, princess?” I stroke my hand down her back and over the curve of her ass.
“The best.” She releases a happy sigh and I feel it settle in my heart.
“What do you want tonight?” I tuck her hair behind her ear.
“I want to sleep with all of you near.” She takes my hand and leads me over to the bed.
I swallow because this woman could lead me into the bowels of hell, and I would willingly follow her. I don’t understand her hold over me, but fuck, I’m not letting this one go or fucking this one over.
She’s mine. As she turns to crawl into the bed with Finn, Wyatt, and Dante, the others watch her with their possessive gazes. She’s our siren. If they want to try to do this thing for real, I’m on board. But I’m the kind of guy that doesn’t mind knocking over a few beehives to see what comes out.
I’m not sure they’re willing to do the same. Sara pulls my hand to bring me onto the bed beside her next to Finn. He smirks and puts his arm beneath his head as he stares up at the ceiling.
Sara snuggles against my side and my heart skips. I want this. But I’m afraid I’m not the kind of guy who can hold on to it.
Sara
Scratching wakes me up. I glance around. Someone left the light on in the bathroom. It casts a dim light into the bedroom.
I sit up and all around me are hot men. A smile lights my face before I can even think about it. I’ve gone from having no one to having four men worship my body at the same time. A shiver races down my spine. Fuck, I want to do that again.
The scratching starts back up and a little whine comes from the door.
Peabody.
He probably just wants to join the cuddle puddle.
Dante snores softly. Wyatt, Drew, and Finn are all out for the count. I slide out of the bed and creep to the door. When I open it, Peabody does little circles and sits at my feet before getting up again.
He needs out. I look back at the bed. They’re all so peaceful. I don’t want to disturb them.
I step into the hallway and close the door. Peabody whines and I whisper, “Just a minute.”
Once in my room, it takes me a few minutes to put on jeans and a sweater with some sneakers. It can be cold outside this late at night. I scoop up Peabody on my way to the front door and grab the leash. I pocket the keycard to get back up and head out.