Page 36 of Their Cruel Play
I turn to look at Natalie. “How are you tonight?”
“Good. This is a great place to watch the people gawk at you guys.” She squints up at me. Her cheeks are flushed and she weaves a little even though she’s seated. Yup, she’s plastered.
I smile and straighten my skirt. “Yeah. How about you, Penny? Having fun?”
She grins. “You should have seen the way Hannah looked at you and Caden. She was furious.”
I turn to search for Hannah, but she’s not there. That means the Cheermonsters are here.
“Can I get a fresh drink for Caden and me?”
Nico nods, but instead of grabbing the bottles, he tugs me down onto his lap. I go willingly. Nat giggles while Pennywatches in fascination. Nico tips my chin up. “It’ll cost you, sunshine.”
Our lips collide and my fingers tangle in his shirt. The sparks are still here. I still want him. I just can’t trust him. He’s not in this solely for me. And he’ll always take the guys’ side against me.
But when he kisses me like this, I want to forget everything. I want him.
He pulls away and I almost lean back in. It’s easier when it’s just sex between us.
His dark eyes hold me for a second. All those feelings I have for him rise inside me, but that’s not important right now.
I lean in close to his ear on Nat’s side. “How about I fuck you tonight as payment?”
Pretty sure that’s not something I would say sober, but the drinking is definitely helping with this mission. Nico slips his hand between us to reposition his cock.
“Whatever you want, sunshine.” Holding me close, he leans over with me in his lap and picks up the cups and bottles. Handing me the cups, he pours a generous portion of rum and some coke into each cup.
When he sets me on my feet, I walk back to Caden. It still feels weird having something in my ass, but I’m getting used to it. I hand a cup to Caden and Luke holds my hips, dragging me down onto his lap.
I take a sip of my drink. Luke takes the cup from me and takes a drink. His throat moves as he swallows. I don’t know why that’s so sexy. Maybe it’s the booze, but I lean in and lick his throat because I can. His fingers clutch into my hip.
The last time I was this buzzed Caden and Luke took me to a bedroom, and fuck, that was hot. He slid his cock against my clit. How would it feel to take Caden’s cock in my throat while Luke pounded into my pussy?
“Don’t get too drunk, princess.” His lips move against my ear. “I want you aware of every inch you take tonight.”
My pussy clenches at the thought of him fucking me more. I’m sure once Jack fucks my ass Luke will want his turn. His fingers press into my waist.
“Well, well, well, if it isn’t the kings and their whores.” Sidney’s voice throws a bucket of water on my sizzling desire. The kings? Didn’t the masked guy use that term for the horsemen?
Her squad joins Sidney, standing in front of us. Hannah, Emma, and Ashley. All of them are dressed in crop shirts and low riding jeans or short skirts.
“Is Harper not enough for you guys that you needed to bring back ups?” Sidney makes a sad face at me. “That didn’t take long.”
“What do you want?” Luke relaxes back into the couch, but his fingers are still tense on my hip. His eyes are hooded. I lay my head on his shoulder and watch them closely. What game are they playing now?
“We brought your jerseys since we’re done with them.” Sidney gestures and a freshman on the cheerleading squad moves forward holding the jerseys, neatly folded and stacked.
Jack stands and takes them. He sets them on the table behind the couch.
“Anything else?” Luke sounds almost bored, but that tension still lingers in his touch.
“I wanted to apologize to Harper again about the perfume.” Sidney smiles with a touch of condescending pity. “I figured you wouldn’t mind, Luke, since you love the way I smell.”
Luke shifts quickly, his nose in my neck, breathing me in. I gasp softly as desire sweeps through me, hot and throbbing. His pale blue eyes lift to mine, and I see the hint of amusement in them.
“Funny, she doesn’t smell like your skanky perfume.” Luke nuzzles my neck with his scruff on his jaw. I try not to make any noises as awareness drips through me, making me press my thighs together. “She smells like me all over.”
The way he saysall overmakes my cheeks heat. I’ve been less than subtle with the girls, and I haven’t even gotten to Eli and Jack, but Luke takes it to another level. After all, he’s claimed me in all ways but one.
